Connecticut Murder Case: Former Girlfriend Speaks Out on Cole Werhan’s History Before Janina Brooke Murphy’s Death

New reporting is renewing attention on the murder case against Cole Theodore Werhan, the Connecticut man accused of killing his girlfriend, 26-year-old Janina Brooke Murphy, inside his own home in March. Court filings unsealed in recent weeks have added two things to the case that weren’t public when Werhan was first arrested: a former partner’s account of alleged threats and violent behavior, and a documented history of pending domestic violence charges that predate his relationship with Murphy entirely.

Janina Brooke Murphy

Cole Theodore Werhan

What Happened on March 29

Connecticut State Police responded to Werhan’s home on Claire Hill Road in Burlington just before 11:15 p.m. on March 29, after Farmington police received a call reporting that a woman had fallen down the stairs and needed medical attention. When officers arrived, they found Werhan outside near the back porch, with what a state police warrant later described as dried blood visible on his face and legs.

Inside, officers found Murphy lying under a blanket on the living room floor. She had signs of trauma to her face, arms, and legs, according to the warrant, and was pronounced dead at the scene shortly before midnight.

Werhan told police at the time that he and Murphy had started dating two months earlier, that the two had known each other in college, and that she’d moved into his home shortly after they reconnected. His account of what happened that night has shifted, according to the warrant: he initially told officers both he and Murphy had fallen down the stairs together, but later gave a different statement at the police station. He told the responding detective that Murphy had gone through his phone, found text messages with two other women, and became upset — and that she then, in his account, began hitting her own head against something before what he described as a fall.

Investigators noted inconsistencies between that account and the physical evidence at the scene, including a “blood-like substance” they observed on his bed. Werhan was not arrested immediately. Connecticut State Police spent the following weeks investigating the death as suspicious before formally charging him with murder.

A History That Predates Murphy

What’s made this case draw sustained attention isn’t only the circumstances of Murphy’s death — it’s what court records show about Werhan before he ever met her.

At the time of his arrest, Werhan had at least two open domestic violence cases pending against him in Connecticut courts. One stemmed from a November 2025 incident and included charges of breach of peace, third-degree assault, disorderly conduct, unlawful restraint, and threatening, with a bond of $75,000 attached. A separate case involved a different former partner, who told investigators she left the relationship because she believed that if she went back to him, she would end up dead. In that case, Werhan faced charges of second-degree strangulation, second-degree threatening, and disorderly conduct.

A prosecutor described Werhan in court as an extreme danger to the community while arguing for the $5 million bond a judge ultimately set at his arraignment.

The Former Girlfriend’s Account

The most recently unsealed material in the case is a redacted police report describing an interview with another former girlfriend of Werhan’s — a relationship that predates his time with Murphy. According to the filing, she told investigators he frequently talked about killing people, and described one specific incident in which he allegedly tried to get her to bring a friend over to his home so that he could kill them.

Those allegations haven’t been tested in a courtroom and aren’t charges in themselves — they’re witness statements included in filings related to the pending murder case. But taken together with the two prior domestic violence cases already on the record, they’ve shifted how the case is being discussed publicly: less as an isolated, sudden act of violence, and more as the latest and most severe point in a pattern several women say they’d already seen.

Werhan has not entered a plea. His attorney, Noah Kores, has said Werhan will plead not guilty in the normal course of proceedings and will raise his defense at the appropriate stage of the case.

Who Janina Brooke Murphy Was

Murphy grew up in the Duxbury and Marlborough, Massachusetts area and graduated from Duxbury High School in 2017. She would have turned 27 the week her death was ruled a homicide. Friends described her as an artistic, kind person — the kind of description that risks getting lost once a case becomes defined by the person accused rather than the person who died.

A close friend, Lindsay Bolduc, told reporters she and Murphy met Werhan through online gaming before Murphy moved in with him, and that she’d had an unshakable feeling something was wrong in the time before Murphy’s death. She was also direct about how she wants Murphy remembered: not only as a victim, but as a full person — someone who was, in her words, so much more than the way this case has come to define her publicly.

Murphy’s mother, Beth Murphy, has spoken to local reporters as well, saying the homicide ruling confirmed what the family had feared from the beginning — that her daughter’s death wasn’t an accident.

Where the Case Stands

Werhan remains held on $5 million bond. He has not yet entered a formal plea to the murder charge, and his attorney has indicated a not guilty plea is expected as the case proceeds. As of this writing, no trial date has been publicly set.

Everything in this article describing Werhan’s alleged actions — on the night of Murphy’s death and in the incidents described by former partners — reflects claims made in police warrants, court filings, and witness statements. None of it has been proven in court, and Werhan is presumed innocent unless and until a jury finds otherwise.


This post will be updated as the case develops.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name