The Mosquito You Can’t Seem to Swat”: Kaylee Goncalves’ Father Says He’s Ready for a Kohberger Retrial
More than a year after Bryan Kohberger stood in an Idaho courtroom and admitted, under oath, that he murdered four University of Idaho students, he’s trying to take it back — and the victims’ families are not staying quiet about it.
What Happened in the Original Case
Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Madison Mogen, 21, Xana Kernodle, 20, and Ethan Chapin, 20, were stabbed to death in the early morning hours of November 13, 2022, inside an off-campus rental house in Moscow, Idaho. Two roommates in the home were unharmed. Kohberger was arrested weeks later, in December 2022.
In July 2025, just a month before jury selection was set to begin, Kohberger accepted a plea deal: he would plead guilty to all four murders in exchange for prosecutors taking the death penalty off the table. When Judge Steven Hippler asked him directly whether he was pleading guilty because he was in fact guilty, Kohberger answered, “Yes.” He waived his right to appeal and was sentenced to four consecutive life terms without parole.
Not every family accepted the deal quietly. Kaylee Goncalves’ father, Steve Goncalves, called it “anything but justice” at the time, telling NewsNation’s Ashleigh Banfield that no majority of the victims’ families believed the arrangement was acceptable.
Kohberger Now Says He Was “Duped”
That, apparently, wasn’t the end of it. In a statement provided to the New York Times and in a new court filing, Kohberger now claims his guilty plea was the product of “false promises and blatant disinformation,” and that his “actual innocence” means the plea must be withdrawn. He has waived his right to appeal, but that doesn’t stop him from filing a new case challenging whether the plea itself was valid.
According to reporting on the filing, Kohberger alleges his own defense attorney, Anne Taylor, frightened him and his family with descriptions of death row conditions and pushed him toward a false confession he didn’t actually want to make. The filing reportedly points to clumps of hair found in one victim’s hand — Ethan Chapin’s — that did not match Kohberger’s DNA, though a reporter who reviewed the underlying photos pushed back on the word “clumps.”
Kohberger did not explain, in either the statement or the filing, what specific promises he says were broken. He has never offered a motive for the killings, and he still hasn’t.
The Goncalves Family’s Response
Steve Goncalves didn’t hold back. Speaking with NewsNation, he said he would “love” a retrial and a second chance to hold Kohberger accountable “to the full extent of what he’s done.” He added that his community has already been “put through the wringer” defending against someone who was never part of it to begin with.
![]() |
| Steve Goncalves |
The wider Goncalves family followed with a pointed written statement, rejecting the idea that anyone misled Kohberger. They noted that when he entered his plea, he never claimed to be uninformed, pressured, or shortchanged on evidence — despite having had two years with his legal team to raise any of that. They also pushed back on the “disinformation” claim directly, pointing out prosecutors’ promise that the plea would waive all appeals, and said the family “knew that wasn’t factual” even then.
The family’s statement didn’t spare Kohberger’s characterization of himself, either — reducing his renewed innocence claims to a break from solitary confinement and a chance for attention. One line from that statement has already started circulating widely online, dubbing Kohberger the “mosquito you just can’t seem to swat.”
Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador said his office is prepared to “do whatever is necessary to ensure justice is fully carried out.”
What Happens Next
For now, Kohberger remains convicted and sentenced. Whether his petition to withdraw the plea goes anywhere is a legal question that hasn’t been decided — courts don’t grant these often, and prosecutors are expected to fight it. But if it succeeds, the case could return to where it was headed before the plea deal: a trial, with the death penalty back on the table, and a jury the Goncalves family says they’re fully confident in.
This case is ongoing and facts may develop. This article reflects reporting available as of late July 2026.



Comments
Post a Comment