We’re About to Kill My Family”: Inside the East St. Louis Murders Allegedly Plotted by Two Teenagers

There’s a specific kind of horror that comes from realizing a crime wasn’t impulsive — that it was planned, discussed, agreed to in writing, days before it happened. That’s the detail that has made the East St. Louis case impossible to look away from. Prosecutors say a 15-year-old girl and her 16-year-old boyfriend didn’t just kill five of her family members. They talked about it first, over text, and then carried it out one by one.


A Killing Spread Across Days, Not Hours

For a while, investigators believed this was a single, chaotic weekend attack. It wasn’t. According to charging documents, the violence actually began around July 5th, days before the case became public, when Cherie May — the girl’s 49-year-old aunt — was killed and her body left inside a storage tote, dumped at Godfree Homes.

Cherie May, 49

The rest unfolded rapidly between July 11th and 12th. Devin May, 24, Cherie’s son, went looking for his mother after he hadn’t heard from her. Police say he found Ja’ymier Davis and the girl inside her aunt’s apartment — and was shot and killed on the spot. Then, according to prosecutors, the 15-year-old went outside and lured her own grandmother, 74-year-old Patricia May, into the apartment, where Davis was allegedly waiting in a closet to ambush her.
Devin May, 24

74-year-old Patricia May

Two more relatives — siblings Quentin Thompson, 21, and Shania Thompson, 25 — were killed at separate locations: Jones Park and a home near 39th Street and Summit Avenue. Two additional victims were shot and wounded but survived.
Quentin Thompson, 21

Shania Thompson, 25


Five people. Three locations. One family.

The Detail That Made This Case National News

If the killings themselves weren’t disturbing enough, one allegation pushed the case into a different category entirely. Prosecutors say Davis cut off Patricia May’s thumb after killing her — not as an act of rage, but of access. Investigators later found the thumb in the center console of his vehicle, allegedly used to unlock her iPhone.

It’s the kind of detail that’s hard to process, and it’s part of why this case has drawn comparisons to some of the coldest, most calculated crimes to make headlines this year.

“I’ll Do It for Me, But Will You Do It for We”

Perhaps the most chilling evidence prosecutors have presented isn’t physical — it’s written. During a pretrial hearing, prosecutors read aloud from a string of Instagram messages exchanged between the two teens in the lead-up to the killings, including the girl allegedly writing, “We about to kill my family,” and later asking Davis, “I’ll do it for me but will you do it for we.” Davis, prosecutors say, responded “yes.”

The girl’s mother had already sensed something was wrong before any of this became public. She’d reported her gun stolen and suspected her daughter had taken it. She’d also seen threatening messages between the two teens — including what’s been described as a family “hit list” — and had gone to police about it.

The girl’s father, Marcus May, later told reporters that his daughter had grown angry with family members after being pulled from regular school and placed in homeschooling, and that she’d run away from home more than once in the weeks before the killings. He lost his mother, sister, and nephew in the attack — meaning he is both the father of one of the accused and a survivor mourning three of the victims.



How It Ended

The two teens were arrested Sunday afternoon, July 12th, after Illinois State Police performed a precision immobilization maneuver to stop their vehicle at Frank Holten State Park. Davis has since appeared in court facing 12 charges as an adult, including five counts of first-degree murder, one count of dismembering a human body, attempted murder, aggravated battery, aggravated vehicular hijacking, and unlawful use of a stolen firearm. A judge ordered him held without bond, calling the sequence of events “horrifying” and finding no conditions that could safely allow his release.

His defense attorney has pushed back hard against the state’s narrative, arguing that Davis was not the aggressor but the target — telling the court, “This is not a case where he is the hunter. He is the hunted.” Prosecutors, for their part, say Davis initially claimed self-defense before ultimately confessing to the killings.

The 15-year-old girl’s case is moving through juvenile court for now, though prosecutors are actively seeking to have her transferred to adult criminal court given the severity of the charges. Investigators say she was the one who told them where to find at least one of the victims’ bodies.

A Family Left to Grieve and Explain

What makes this case so difficult to sit with isn’t just the violence — it’s the intimacy of it. This wasn’t a stranger, a break-in, a random act. It was a granddaughter and her boyfriend, allegedly moving methodically through her own family: an aunt, a cousin, a grandmother, two siblings. Illinois State Police Director Brendan Kelly summed it up bluntly at a press conference: “These alleged acts of horrific violence, taking this number of lives, here in this community — it’s terrible. It’s evil, but it will not keep this city down.”

For Marcus May, there’s no clean way to hold both truths — that his daughter is accused of orchestrating the deaths of people he loved, and that he still has to find a way to grieve them. The case is now headed toward a grand jury, with more details expected to surface as it moves through the courts.

We’ll continue following this case as it develops, including the outcome of the juvenile transfer hearing and any further charges.


This article is based on court documents, official statements from the Illinois State Police and St. Clair County State’s Attorney’s Office, and reporting from local and national news outlets covering the case. Charges reflect allegations that have not yet been proven in court.




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name