The Divorce Attorney Who Waited 12 Years to Get Caught

On a Sunday evening in March 2013, a 53-year-old nurse named Aliza Sherman walked toward a downtown Cleveland office building for a meeting that would never happen. She never made it through the door. Someone came up behind her, stabbed her eleven times, and disappeared into the city before anyone could see a face. For more than a decade, the person responsible was a shadow on a grainy security tape — hooded, faceless, gone.

Aliza Sherman 


Then, in 2025, investigators arrested the one person who had been sitting in plain sight the entire time: Aliza’s own divorce attorney.

A Meeting She Never Reached

Aliza Sherman was a fertility nurse at the Cleveland Clinic and a mother of four. By the spring of 2013, she was in the middle of a bitter, drawn-out divorce, and her case was scheduled to go to trial the very next morning. That Sunday, March 24, she headed to the Galleria at Erieview in downtown Cleveland to meet with her divorce lawyer, Gregory Moore, ahead of the proceedings.

Gregory Moore


She never made it inside his office. Just after 5 p.m., as she walked through the plaza, someone attacked her from behind, stabbing her eleven times before fleeing on foot. A 911 caller found her on the sidewalk, barely able to speak. The only words she could get out were, “I’m dying.” She was rushed to MetroHealth Medical Center, where she died just over an hour later.

Security cameras in the area captured a hooded figure running from the scene, but the footage was never clear enough to identify who was underneath the hood. No weapon was ever recovered. And with her divorce trial due to start the following morning, the timing alone was enough to make investigators suspicious — but suspicion wasn’t evidence, and the case went cold.

A Community That Refused to Let Go

What makes this case stand out from so many unsolved homicides is how loudly the people who loved Aliza kept fighting for her. Her four children organized “Justice for Aliza” rallies for years after her death. Friends and former colleagues from the Cleveland Clinic raised over $23,000 in reward money on top of what Crime Stoppers offered. Every March, a group of her family and friends returned to the site of the attack to mark the anniversary and keep her story in front of the public.

It’s the kind of sustained, grassroots pressure that rarely gets talked about in true crime coverage, but it’s often what keeps a cold case from staying cold forever. Investigators kept working the file in the background, even as a decade passed with no arrest.

The Twist Nobody Saw Coming

In May 2025 — more than twelve years after the murder — a Cuyahoga County grand jury secretly indicted Gregory Moore, the very attorney Aliza had been on her way to see. He was arrested by U.S. Marshals in Austin, Texas, and extradited back to Ohio to face charges including aggravated murder, conspiracy, and kidnapping.

Prosecutors allege a chilling motive: that Moore didn’t want to go to trial in Aliza’s divorce case, and arranged for her to be “unavailable” so he wouldn’t have to. It’s worth noting that Moore was not entirely unknown to law enforcement before this. Back in 2013, shortly after the murder, he was separately indicted for making bomb threats against courthouses in two different Ohio counties — a charge he ultimately pleaded guilty to, serving jail time and probation years before he was ever connected to Aliza’s death.

Moore has pleaded not guilty to the murder charges, and as with anyone facing trial, he is presumed innocent unless and until a jury decides otherwise.

Where the Case Stands Today

The trial has been building toward a decisive moment. Hearings over the past year have included testimony from law enforcement officials and people connected to Aliza’s estranged husband, some of it presented publicly for the first time in over a decade. Prosecutors say the case will lean heavily on cellphone records and location data from the day of the murder. The defense, in turn, has pushed back on how that evidence was obtained and has raised questions about a threatening message allegedly left at Aliza’s workplace — suggesting an alternate theory investigators may not have fully chased down.

Just this week, prosecutors asked the court for permission to take the jury physically to the scene of the crime — the stretch of downtown Cleveland between the Galleria and the plaza where Aliza was killed — before opening statements even begin. It’s an unusual step, and it signals how much prosecutors believe the geography of that evening matters to their case.

Why This Case Still Resonates

Aliza Sherman’s murder taps into one of the more unsettling ideas in true crime: that the person meant to protect your interests can also be the one working against them. Divorce proceedings are already among the most emotionally charged legal processes a person can go through, built on a foundation of trust between client and attorney. If prosecutors are right, that trust was the exact thing exploited.

It’s also a story about time. Twelve years is a long time to wait for an answer, long enough for grief to calcify into something else — a kind of stubborn hope that refuses to quit. Aliza’s daughter, Jennifer, put it simply not long after the arrest: her family had been “living this nightmare” for over a decade, just wanting the truth.

Whatever the jury ultimately decides, Aliza Sherman’s case is a reminder that “cold” doesn’t mean “closed” — and that some families never stop pushing for the door to open again.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name