Chris Watts Has Found “Love” Behind Bars — And He’s Had Plenty of Practice

There’s a special kind of horror in watching a convicted family annihilator get fan mail. Yet that’s exactly the reality for Chris Watts, the Colorado man serving three consecutive life sentences for murdering his pregnant wife and two young daughters in August 2018 — and, according to a wave of recent reporting, he’s never really stopped attracting women who want to be close to him.

Chris Watts

Chris Watts and his family


The Latest Chapter

The most recent development centers on a woman identified as Lizzie Henderson, a 39-year-old realtor who reportedly relocated from Ohio to Wisconsin specifically to be closer to Watts’s cell at Dodge Correctional Institution in Waupun. Court filings reportedly show she’s applied to legally change her name, and she’s been photographed wearing a ring on her wedding finger. Prison visit logs allegedly show she’s visited Watts around 20 times in the past year, including spending Christmas Day with him.

Lizzie Henderson


When asked how the relationship began, Henderson reportedly described it only as something between herself, Watts, and God — acknowledging that outsiders might see the whole thing as unsettling. She also said she’d want to be respectful of the victims’ loved ones, even while continuing the relationship.

If that sounds like déjà vu, it’s because this isn’t the first time Watts has made headlines for romance from behind bars.

A Pattern, Not an Isolated Story

Since his 2018 conviction, Watts has reportedly maintained written relationships with a rotating cast of pen pals — some who say they were drawn in by his letters referencing Bible verses and personal redemption. In letters to one woman, he reportedly compared his suffering in prison to the suffering of Jesus, framing his incarceration as part of a divine plan rather than a consequence he earned.

Another pen pal has described their communication evolving over time, saying Watts eventually began sharing details about his affair with Nichol Kessinger — the coworker he was sleeping with at the time of the murders — that went well beyond what she expected from what she initially saw as a supportive, almost maternal correspondence.

Even Kessinger herself, who changed her identity and disappeared from public life after Watts’s arrest, has reportedly stayed in indirect contact with him, according to a fellow inmate who claimed she reached out under a different name to “clear some things up.”

Add in a former prison psychologist who developed what’s been described as a close, intimate bond with Watts — a relationship notable enough to become the subject of a Lifetime true-crime series — and you get a picture of a man who has spent his entire incarceration surrounded by women eager to understand, forgive, or simply be near him.

Why Do People Do This?

It’s one of the most uncomfortable questions in true crime, and there’s no single answer. Some researchers point to hybristophilia — an attraction to people who’ve committed violent crimes — as a genuine, if rare, psychological phenomenon. Others suggest it’s less about attraction to violence and more about a desire to “save” or be chosen by someone infamous, or simply the pull of being at the center of a story everyone is talking about.

Whatever the explanation, Watts himself has shown a consistent pattern in his letters: casting himself as reformed, forgiven, and misunderstood, while shifting blame for the murders onto Kessinger, describing her at one point as having led him away from the right path. It’s the same instinct for self-serving narrative control that marked his original, ever-changing confession back in 2018 — first denying involvement, then blaming Shanann, before finally admitting what really happened.

The Bottom Line

Chris Watts strangled his pregnant wife and smothered his two young daughters, disposing of their bodies at an oil work site, all so he could be free to pursue an affair. Nearly eight years later, he’s still finding women willing to write him letters, visit him, and in at least one case, plan a life with him — a strange and uncomfortable footnote to one of the most devastating domestic murder cases of the last decade.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name