Karmelo Anthony Seeks a New Trial — And the Records Both Sides Agreed to Hide Are Now Public
For more than a year, there was an agreement nobody outside the courtroom knew about.
Before Karmelo Anthony stood trial for the murder of Austin Metcalf, both the prosecution and the defense quietly agreed to keep each teenager’s behavioral history out of the courtroom entirely — off the record, never signed, never disclosed to the public. The goal, according to testimony this week, was to keep the trial focused narrowly on what happened under that tent at a Frisco track meet, and nothing else.
![]() |
| Karmelo Anthony |
![]() |
| Austin Metcalf |
That agreement just fell apart in open court.
Why This Is Happening Now
Anthony, now 19, is serving a 35-year sentence for fatally stabbing Metcalf, 17, during a confrontation at a high school track meet in April 2025. He’s now asking for a new trial, and this week’s hearing in front of retired Judge Michael Chitty at the Collin County courthouse is where that request is being argued.
As part of that motion, Anthony’s new attorney, Russell Wilson, is pushing to have the two teenagers’ prior conduct — the material both sides agreed to bury during the original trial — brought into the open. His argument is that keeping it hidden helped produce an unfair trial. Anthony’s original defense attorney, Mike Howard, testified this week about exactly what was in the background report the jury never saw.
The result: two competing case files, both previously sealed by agreement, both now spilling into public record at once.
What’s Being Said About Austin Metcalf
According to the defense’s motion and Howard’s testimony, Austin Metcalf’s disciplinary file goes back years and includes more than fifty documented allegations — fights, assaults, suspensions, and messages containing slurs or references to violence.
Specific incidents cited in court documents include a 2018 accusation, while Austin and his twin brother Hunter were still in elementary school, that the two assaulted a female student, leading to an arrest. Court records also describe an incident in which Austin and Hunter were caught spray-painting racist graffiti — including phrases referencing the KKK and Nazi imagery, along with a racial slur — which resulted in a year of juvenile probation. A 2023 allegation accuses Austin of bullying a Black classmate. Disciplinary records from 2022 through 2024 reportedly document Austin using profanity toward a teacher on seven separate occasions, and one incident where he was banned from attending a season of basketball games after yelling at players.
One specific exchange has drawn particular attention. According to the motion, during a previous track meet, another student texted Austin that someone near their bench was “talking wild.” Austin’s reported reply was to tell the student to kill him — using a derogatory term for the person in question.
Metcalf’s father has responded publicly and firmly, pushing back against the idea that his son’s juvenile record should now be aired in connection with his death.
What’s Being Said About Karmelo Anthony
The material being released isn’t one-sided. Prosecutors have separately pushed back with their own set of previously excluded information about Anthony.
According to prosecutor testimony, messages attributed to Anthony described violent fantasies, including references to stabbing someone and reacting to blood on a blade. One text message attributed to him reportedly read, “I’m lowkey on the verge.” Prosecutors say school records show Anthony had previously been enrolled in a program addressing behavioral issues, and they’ve argued that his messages in the lead-up to the track meet show he arrived, in their words, “spoiling for a fight.”
None of this was presented to the jury that convicted him, either — a direct result of the same off-the-record agreement now under scrutiny.
Why the Agreement Existed — and Why It’s Unraveling
Testimony this week suggests the agreement was never formalized in writing specifically because both sides worried the material could leak and taint the jury pool in a case that was already drawing national attention. For over a year, it worked. Neither the jury nor the public saw either background file.
Anthony’s new legal team argues that the agreement became a constitutional problem the moment prosecutors indicated its protections might not apply if Anthony chose to testify — effectively, they argue, forcing him to choose between silence and having his own excluded history used against him anyway. That argument is now central to the case for a new trial.
Where the Case Stands
Nothing has been decided yet. This week’s hearing is focused on whether Anthony is entitled to a new trial at all — not on re-litigating guilt or innocence directly. Judge Chitty has not yet ruled.
What’s already changed is public: two files that were deliberately kept sealed during the original trial, each containing allegations neither side wanted tested in front of a jury, are now part of the public record — and part of a very public argument over whether the first trial was fair to begin with.
We’ll continue following this case and update this article when Judge Chitty rules on the retrial motion.
This article is based on court testimony and reporting from CBS News Texas, WFAA, The Dallas Morning News, USA Herald, and NewsNation as of August 21, 2026. The allegations described above regarding both Austin Metcalf and Karmelo Anthony are drawn from court motions and testimony and have not been proven in a trial.


Comments
Post a Comment