A Colorado Art Teacher Was Found Dead in Her Shower. Her Husband’s Story Didn’t Match the Blood.

On the morning of August 13, a 911 dispatcher in Jefferson County, Colorado took a call from a man who said his wife had cut her own throat. He gave the address, mentioned two young children were in the house, and said the knife was sitting in the shower next to her body. Ten minutes later, officers walked into a home on South Welch Circle in Lakewood and found 37-year-old Lindsey Barnett dead in the master bathroom shower, just as her husband described.

Lindsey Barnett 


But almost nothing else about the scene matched what he’d told them.

Who Was Lindsey Barnett

Lindsey Barnett taught art at two Jefferson County elementary schools, Hutchinson and Westgate. Colleagues described her as the kind of teacher who gave more than the job required — organizing special projects, pouring extra energy into the district’s art show, making sure every kid felt seen in her classroom. Hutchinson’s principal called her a “sweet soul” with an “extraordinary dedication” to her students. When word of her death reached families that Friday, both schools had to figure out how to open for the school year without her.

She was 37. She had two young children. And according to her own mother, she had been trying for months to get out of a marriage that had turned frightening.

What Her Husband Told Police

Patrick Theodore Barnett, known as Ted, is 40 years old. When investigators arrived, he told them he and Lindsey had been sleeping separately for months due to marital problems — he in the basement, she in the main bedroom upstairs. He said the two had argued about dinner the night before, that he’d last seen her alive between 10 and 10:30 p.m., and that he woke up the next morning to find her unresponsive in the shower with a severe cut to her neck.

Patrick Theodore Barnett


His explanation, in short: she had done this to herself.

The Evidence That Didn’t Add Up

Investigators started finding problems almost immediately. A large amount of blood had soaked into the mattress in the main bedroom — not the bathroom where Ted said she died. A blood trail led from that bedroom to the shower, suggesting her body, or at least her blood, had traveled between the two rooms. Detectives also found a small, “dainty” footprint in blood at the scene, according to the arrest affidavit.

Ted Barnett had no explanation for how his wife’s body would have moved from the bed to the shower on its own. When detectives brought him in for a second round of questioning and told him investigators believed she died in the bed rather than the shower, he stuck to his original account, saying only that he had “no knowledge of what happened.”

He also had fresh scratches across his body — and gave three different explanations for them over the course of the investigation.

Lindsey’s mother disputed the self-harm narrative entirely when detectives interviewed her. She described her son-in-law as controlling and verbally abusive, someone who had anger issues and would yell while her daughter stayed calm and quiet. She told police that two to four months before Lindsey’s death, her daughter had shown up at her parents’ house alone, late at night, because she needed to get away from him.

A Girlfriend Enters the Picture

The same afternoon Lindsey was found dead, Lakewood police got an unexpected phone call. A woman identified herself as Ted Barnett’s girlfriend and asked officers to do a welfare check on him. She told them she was worried he hadn’t been honest with her about something — and by the time she called, investigators were already piecing together a timeline that suggested Ted’s version of events was falling apart.

Whether or how that relationship connects to the case is still unfolding, but it added another layer to a story that already looked nothing like the “she took her own life” explanation Ted gave when he first called 911.

Where the Case Stands Now

Ted Barnett was arrested later that same day on suspicion of first-degree murder and is being held without bond at the Jefferson County Detention Center. Lakewood Detective Victoria Wagner, who wrote the arrest affidavit, said she found probable cause for the arrest largely because Barnett “constantly made inconsistent statements throughout the investigation.”

He has not been formally charged. That decision rests with the First Judicial District Attorney’s Office, and he’s scheduled to make a court appearance on August 20. Under the law, he is presumed innocent unless and until proven otherwise.

For now, two elementary schools are trying to help students process the loss of a teacher they loved, and a family is left with the kind of contradictions that only come out after someone insists a death was something it wasn’t.

If you or someone you know is in a relationship affected by domestic violence, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is available 24/7 at 1-800-799-7233.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name