A Fourth Arrest in the Murder of Sherri Mitko — What We Know So Far
Eight days after 70-year-old Sherri Mitko was found shot to death inside her own home in rural Pulaski County, Kentucky, investigators added a fourth name to the list of people facing charges. On August 19, the Pulaski County Sheriff’s Office announced that another teenage boy had been arrested and charged with complicity to commit murder — a case that keeps widening even as the community tries to make sense of how a robbery for a few hundred dollars ended in a grandmother’s death.
![]() |
| Sherri Mitko |
How It Started
Sherri Mitko was a substitute teacher in neighboring Laurel County, remembered by those who knew her for the wedding dresses and baked goods she made by hand and for the encouragement she was quick to hand out. She lived on Lower Line Creek Road in eastern Pulaski County, and it was there, just before 1:20 a.m. on August 12, that deputies were dispatched after an open 911 line picked up voices in the background of the call.
What they captured was chilling: two young male voices, talking about blood, a safe, and — according to the arrest complaint — the words “we should not have killed her.” When deputies arrived, they found Mitko dead from multiple gunshot wounds.
The First Three Arrests
The sheriff’s office moved quickly. By August 16, two teenagers — ages 15 and 17 — were taken into custody and charged with murder. According to investigators, the 17-year-old was the one who fired the shots that killed Mitko, while the 15-year-old later told police the pair made off with roughly $240 in cash and some alcohol from the home.
A day later, the case expanded to include an adult. Twenty-year-old McCoy Chaney of Somerset was arrested and charged with murder, first-degree robbery, and first-degree burglary. Investigators say Chaney drove the two teens to Mitko’s house and away from it afterward. Chaney, for his part, has told reporters from jail that he didn’t know what the others were planning — he says he believed he was simply dropping them off to pick something up at a friend’s place, and that he panicked when he heard gunshots but was too afraid of the other suspects to come forward sooner. He’s currently held on a $1.5 million bond.
![]() |
| McCoy Chaney |
Sheriff Bobby Jones has described the killing as an isolated, targeted incident — investigators believe at least one of the suspects had been to Mitko’s home before and knew her.
Suspect Number Four
Now the case has grown again. On August 19, authorities announced that a fourth person — another teenage boy — has been charged with complicity to commit murder. Because he’s a juvenile, his name hasn’t been released, and the sheriff’s office has said little beyond confirming the charge. It’s not yet clear whether he was present at the house the night Mitko was killed, or whether his alleged role was set up beforehand — the kind of detail that will likely come out as the case moves through juvenile court.
What is clear is that a crime originally described as involving two teenagers and a getaway driver has now pulled in a fourth person, and Sheriff Jones has indicated more arrests could still be coming.
The Questions That Remain
Cases like this one tend to sit with people longer than the headlines suggest, and it’s not hard to see why. A woman is dead over an amount of money that wouldn’t cover a week of groceries. Four people, most of them barely old enough to drive, are now facing the consequences. And the picture of exactly who knew what, and when, is still being pieced together one arrest at a time.
For now, McCoy Chaney remains in the Pulaski County Detention Center awaiting further proceedings, and the three juveniles face their charges in a system built to handle cases differently than it would for adults — even ones this serious. As with any case involving minors, all suspects are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.
We’ll continue to follow this case as it develops.


Comments
Post a Comment