Ohio Mom Who Studied Homicidal Teens Allegedly Killed by Her Own Daughter
Twenty-four years before her death, Dr. Tamela Dutcher co-authored an academic paper on why adolescents commit homicide. On August 14, 2026, authorities say her own 18-year-old daughter helped plan her murder.
![]() |
| Left: Dr Tamela——Right: Her Daughter |
The Shooting on Bean-Oller Road
Just after midnight, a 911 caller reported a shooting at a home on Bean-Oller Road, south of Delaware, Ohio. When deputies arrived, they found 55-year-old Tamela Dutcher suffering from multiple gunshot wounds, including one to the face. She had been shot while sitting on the couch in her living room. Her husband, Neil King, called 911 and was reportedly shot at as well while kneeling down to help her — a second bullet was later found lodged in a wall where he’d been standing. Tamela was rushed to the hospital, where she was pronounced dead hours later.
Investigators quickly zeroed in on two men: 20-year-old Christian Evans and his roommate, 21-year-old Dajameous Payne. A neighbor’s surveillance camera reportedly captured the pair leaving the property. Both were arrested and charged with murder.
But it’s the third arrest that turned this into a story nobody could stop talking about — because the third person charged was Tamela’s own daughter.
“If I Were You, I Would Have Killed Her”
Bryanna Dutcher, 18, was first arrested on a lesser charge: obstruction of justice. She told police she’d been in the “dog room” cleaning when she heard gunshots, that she hadn’t seen anyone enter the home, and that she couldn’t think of anyone angry enough to hurt her parents — though she floated the name of a family friend who allegedly owed her mother money.
According to a probable cause affidavit, the real story started brewing the day before. On August 13, Bryanna and her mother got into a heated argument about cleaning. It reportedly wasn’t the first flare-up between the two that week — days earlier, police had been called to Evans’ apartment after Bryanna and Evans were “roughhousing” and she hit her throat on a wall.
While venting to Evans, her boyfriend, about the fight with her mother, Bryanna says he told her, “If I were you, I would have killed her.” That night, Evans and Payne reportedly showed up at the house, but Bryanna said she had chores and couldn’t leave. About 15 minutes later, she told police, she heard a gunshot.
Investigators say deleted text messages recovered from Bryanna’s phone tell a different story — one that allegedly shows her and Evans discussing the plan in advance, with one message reading, “this has to be perfect.” Prosecutors believe Evans brought the gun into the house. They have not said who fired it.
Bryanna also told deputies that her parents were “very racist” toward Evans, who is Black, and claimed that Payne — Evans’ roommate — had threatened to kidnap her family. Her father reportedly told police there were roughly 100 guns inside the home.
All three — Bryanna Dutcher, Christian Evans, and Dajameous Payne — were indicted on murder charges and appeared virtually for arraignment, each held on a $3 million bond.
The Chilling Coincidence
Long before any of this, Tamela Dutcher was a doctor based in central Ohio, and public records show she co-authored a 2002 academic paper titled “The violent and homicidal adolescent: Hearts darkened before time.” Published six years before Bryanna was born, the paper examined the different typologies behind adolescent murder cases and argued that many violent teens don’t respond to traditional talk therapy — recommending art- and creativity-based treatment instead.
It’s the kind of detail that would feel too on-the-nose in fiction. In real life, it’s just one more layer of tragedy in a case that’s still unfolding.
What’s Next
No trial date has been set. Investigators have not disclosed who is believed to have pulled the trigger, and the full scope of what prosecutors say was a planned attack is still coming out through court filings. We’ll update this post as the case develops.


Comments
Post a Comment