Woman Pleads Guilty to Killing Wife, Had Killed Husband Too
Some cases feel less like a single crime and more like a pattern finally catching up with someone. That’s the disturbing thread running through the story of Yolanda Olejniczak Marodi — a woman who has now pleaded guilty to killing two spouses, more than two decades apart, both times after the relationship started falling apart.
![]() |
| Yolanda Olejniczak Marodi |
A Firefighter’s Life, Cut Short
Rebecca “Becky” Marodi wasn’t just anyone. She’d spent more than 30 years with Cal Fire, starting out as a volunteer in Moreno Valley and working her way up to captain, most recently stationed at the French Valley station in Riverside County. Colleagues remembered her as someone who always had a smile, the kind of person who ran toward danger for a living.
![]() |
| Rebecca “Becky” Marodi |
On the night of February 17, 2025, that danger came from inside her own home.
Rebecca’s mother, Lorena, arrived at the couple’s Ramona home and found a trail of blood leading inside. She found her daughter’s body and called 911. Deputies who responded located Rebecca face down in a hallway with multiple stab wounds — 34 in total, according to prosecutors — to her neck, chest, and back. Firefighters, some of whom recognized their fallen colleague, tried to save her at the scene. She didn’t survive.
What the Ring Camera Caught
According to the arrest warrant, this wasn’t a case built purely on circumstantial evidence. Home surveillance footage reportedly captured Rebecca fleeing the house as her wife, Yolanda, chased after her — knife allegedly visible in hand, blood on her arms. At one point, the wounded, bleeding victim was recorded crying out, pleading not to die.
Investigators say the killing had a clear trigger: Rebecca had told Yolanda about a week earlier that she was ending the marriage. According to the affidavit, Yolanda later wrote to an associate that Becky had come home and admitted she was leaving — that she’d met someone else.
About an hour after the stabbing, Yolanda Marodi crossed the U.S.-Mexico border.
A Month on the Run — With a History Nobody Fully Knew About
What followed was a monthlong international manhunt. On March 22, 2025, Mexican law enforcement located her near a hotel in the Ferrocarril neighborhood of Mexicali, just a few miles south of the border, and turned her over to U.S. Marshals.
It was only as the case unfolded that the full picture of who Yolanda Marodi was came into focus — and it was almost unbelievable. Friends reportedly told reporters they knew she’d displayed controlling and isolating behavior in the relationship, but had no idea about her criminal history. Because more than two decades earlier, in October 2000, Yolanda had been arrested for killing another spouse.
That victim was her then-husband, James Joseph Olejniczak, who died from stab wounds in San Bernardino County. Yolanda pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter in 2003 and served nearly 13 years before her release in 2013 — meaning she walked free, remarried, and, according to prosecutors, ended up repeating the same pattern with a new spouse.
The Guilty Plea
Yolanda Marodi initially pleaded not guilty to Rebecca’s murder. But this week, she reversed course, appearing in El Cajon’s San Diego Superior Court and pleading guilty to second-degree murder. As part of the plea, she also formally admitted to her prior serious felony conviction from the 2000 killing.
She’s scheduled to be sentenced on September 2 and is expected to face 36 years to life in state prison.
Two Marriages, Two Breakups, Two Bodies
What makes this case so unsettling for true crime audiences isn’t just the brutality of the crime — it’s the repetition. Two spouses. Two relationships that were ending. Two people who apparently didn’t survive the process of trying to leave.
Rebecca Marodi spent her life running toward emergencies to save strangers. In the end, the danger that took her life was already living under her own roof.
This article is based on court records, arrest warrant affidavits, and statements from the San Diego County Sheriff’s Office and District Attorney’s Office. Yolanda Marodi is scheduled to be formally sentenced on September 2.


Comments
Post a Comment