15 Years Later, a Wilmington “Jane Doe” Finally Has a Name — And Her Story Isn’t What Anyone Expected

Every cold case has a moment investigators hope for: the phone call, the DNA match, the piece that finally makes the picture whole. For New Castle County Police, that moment came in January of this year, closing out a mystery that had sat unsolved since a summer afternoon in 2011.

But this one didn’t end the way anyone thought it would.

A Skull in the Woods

On June 5, 2011, patrol officers responded to a wooded area of Sellers Park, off Edgemoor Road in Wilmington, after someone reported finding human bones. When detectives arrived, they found partial skeletal remains, including a human skull. An extensive search of the area also turned up a pair of blue shorts near the site.

The remains went to the Delaware Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, where a forensic anthropological analysis determined they belonged to a woman, likely white, somewhere between 25 and 50 years old. Her case information went into the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System, and a DNA profile was logged into CODIS.

And then, for years, nothing. No match. No name. Just a case file marked open.

A Cold Case Squad Takes a Second Look

In 2019, New Castle County’s Cold Case Squad decided the file deserved another look. Forensic science had moved fast in the years since 2011, and investigators believed newer tools might succeed where the originals hadn’t.

They brought in Joe Mullins, a forensic art professor at George Mason University, who used a 3D scan of the skull to build a facial reconstruction — piecing together muscle, tissue depth, and features in an attempt to give the public something to recognize. Mullins has described this kind of work simply: these aren’t just skulls, they’re people who lost their identities somewhere along the way.

The reconstruction went public in 2021, but even with a face and renewed appeals, the case stayed cold for years longer. Investigators eventually turned to forensic investigative genetic genealogy, working with a genealogy detective from Maryland’s Montgomery County Police Department and reaching out to people across the country who were willing to share their own ancestral DNA information.

The Break Nobody Expected

In January, that genealogical outreach finally produced a lead: a potential family connection. When detectives followed it, the story took a turn nobody investigating a 2011 case would have predicted.

The remains found in Sellers Park didn’t belong to a recent missing person at all. They belonged to Hannah Graham Kleitz, a woman who died in 1907 at age 29 from a medical illness — more than a century before her remains turned up in a Wilmington park.

Hannah Graham Kleitz


Kleitz had been laid to rest in a mausoleum at Riverview Cemetery. Investigators learned that her grave had been desecrated in 2002, and that remains matching those recovered later at Sellers Park had been removed from it. Somehow, in the years between that theft and 2011, her remains ended up in the wooded area where officers found them.

A Case Closed, A Century in the Making

For New Castle County Police, the identification closed an investigative loop that had been open for 15 years. For Kleitz’s family, it meant something more personal: the chance to finally reunite her remains and return her to her mausoleum, more than a hundred years after she was first laid there.

It’s a rare kind of resolution in true crime — not an arrest, not a trial, but a name restored and a resting place made whole again. The identification marks the second time Delaware investigators have used advanced DNA identity technology to crack a case that traditional methods couldn’t solve, and it’s a reminder of how far forensic genealogy has come since that skull was first found in the brush back in 2011.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name