Two Wisconsin Teachers Plead Guilty to Sex Crimes Involving Students

A Wisconsin elementary school has become the focus of a disturbing series of criminal cases involving two former fifth-grade teachers who worked at the same school.

Both women have now pleaded guilty to sex crimes involving minors.

The latest development came on September 14, when 25-year-old Abigail Faust, a former fifth-grade teacher at River Crest Elementary School in Hudson, pleaded guilty in St. Croix County Circuit Court to child enticement involving sexual conduct and second-degree sexual assault of a child under 16.

Abigail Faust


According to court records and prosecutors, the charges involved two 15-year-old boys. One was a teenager Faust had been employed to care for as a nanny, while the other was his friend.

But Faust's case became even more complicated because investigators also uncovered information involving her former colleague at River Crest Elementary, Madison Bergmann.

Madison Bergmann


Bergmann had already been convicted of crimes involving an 11-year-old student.

And investigators found text messages between the two teachers discussing their relationships with students, according to court records reported by local news outlets.

The investigation began with another teacher

The investigation involving Faust did not begin as an isolated case.

Hudson police were initially investigating Madison Bergmann, who had been a fifth-grade teacher at River Crest Elementary during the 2023–2024 school year.

Bergmann was accused of having an inappropriate relationship with an 11-year-old student in her classroom.

She ultimately pleaded guilty to one count of child enticement and two counts of sexual misconduct by a school staff member.

In December 2025, Bergmann was sentenced to six years in prison, followed by six years of extended supervision.

The investigation into Bergmann eventually led detectives to information about Faust.

According to the criminal complaint, investigators found text exchanges between Faust and Bergmann in which the two discussed their relationships with students.

Faust's case involved two teenage boys

According to prosecutors, Faust's criminal case involved two 15-year-old boys.

One of them was a teenager whose family had employed Faust as a nanny.

Investigators alleged that Faust developed an inappropriate relationship with the boy while she had access to him as a trusted caregiver.

She later also became involved with the boy's 15-year-old friend, according to court records.

The conduct eventually resulted in criminal charges in both Wisconsin and Minnesota.

Faust pleaded guilty in St. Croix County to the Wisconsin charges on September 14.

She also pleaded guilty earlier this month in Minnesota to third-degree criminal sexual conduct in a related case involving the teenager she had been employed to care for.

Investigators also examined Faust's conduct at school

The investigation uncovered allegations involving one of Faust's own fifth-grade students at River Crest Elementary.

According to the criminal complaint, the student told a therapist that Faust had asked him to remain behind after the other students left the classroom.

The boy alleged that Faust pushed him against a wall and kissed him.

He reportedly told investigators that the incident made him feel scared and uncomfortable. Investigators also found a note containing Faust's personal phone number in the student's backpack.

Those allegations resulted in additional charges against Faust.

However, those charges were dismissed as part of her plea agreement and read into the record, meaning they should not be described as convictions.

That distinction is important because Faust's September guilty plea relates to the separate charges involving the two 15-year-old boys.

Two teachers, one school

Faust and Bergmann were both fifth-grade teachers at River Crest Elementary School in Hudson.

Their cases became connected through the investigation into Bergmann and the evidence investigators recovered during that investigation.

According to court records, the two women communicated with each other about their relationships with students.

The discovery has raised questions about how the conduct came to light and whether warning signs could have been recognized earlier.

However, the available court records and reporting do not establish that school officials knew about the criminal conduct before investigators became involved.

Both women ultimately left their teaching positions at River Crest Elementary.

Bergmann is already serving a prison sentence

Bergmann's case preceded Faust's guilty plea.

She was accused of an inappropriate relationship with an 11-year-old student and had exchanged a large volume of messages with him.

After pleading guilty to three felony counts, Bergmann received a six-year prison sentence in December 2025, followed by six years of extended supervision. She is also required to comply with restrictions related to contact with minors.

Her conviction and sentence were separate from the charges that later resulted in Faust's guilty plea.

Faust is awaiting sentencing

Faust has not yet been sentenced in the Wisconsin case.

Her sentencing hearing is scheduled for December 15, 2026, according to reporting from WEAU.

She also faces sentencing in Minnesota in connection with her guilty plea there.

The criminal cases involving both former teachers have now moved substantially beyond the allegation stage, with Bergmann already sentenced and Faust having entered guilty pleas in two states.

The investigation and court proceedings have nevertheless left unanswered questions about what happened inside the school and when school officials became aware of concerns involving the teachers.

For the families and students affected, the case represents a serious breach of trust involving adults who were placed in positions of authority and responsibility.

As Faust awaits sentencing, the legal proceedings will determine the punishment for the offenses to which she has pleaded guilty.

Sources

WEAU — reporting on Abigail Faust's September 2026 guilty plea and court proceedings

PEOPLE — reporting on the connection between Faust and Madison Bergmann

KARE 11 — earlier reporting on the River Crest Elementary investigation

Minnesota Star Tribune — reporting on the original investigation involving Madison Bergmann


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name