New Jersey Woman Accused of Tinder Hitman Plot Against Ex and His Daughter
A New Jersey woman's alleged attempt to arrange a double murder took an unexpected turn when the person she believed could carry out the killings was secretly working with investigators.
More than a year after the alleged plot was uncovered, Jaclyn D. Diiorio, 28, of Runnemede, New Jersey, is now facing federal charges in connection with an alleged murder-for-hire scheme targeting her former boyfriend and his 19-year-old daughter.
![]() |
| Jaclyn D. Diiorio |
Federal prosecutors announced the indictment on September 9, 2026.
According to the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, Diiorio is accused of using a cellphone to facilitate an interstate murder-for-hire scheme involving two people. She faces two federal counts related to the alleged plot.
The charges are allegations. Diiorio is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
The Alleged Plot Began After a Breakup
The case dates back to March 2025.
According to prosecutors and previously filed court documents, Diiorio had been in a relationship with a Philadelphia police officer identified in court reporting as Matthew O'Hanlon.
The relationship ended in early March 2025.
Within weeks, investigators say Diiorio began discussing a plan to have her former boyfriend killed.
But the alleged plan did not stop with him.
Prosecutors say his 19-year-old daughter was also targeted.
The alleged plot eventually led Diiorio to someone she believed could help carry it out.
There was just one problem.
He wasn't actually a hitman.
The Person She Met on Tinder Was Working With Investigators
According to prosecutors, Diiorio connected with a confidential informant through Tinder.
The two allegedly exchanged messages and phone calls between March 30 and April 5, 2025, as they discussed the proposed killings.
Investigators say Diiorio eventually met the informant in person.
One of those meetings reportedly took place at a Wawa in Runnemede on March 31.
A few days later, another meeting took place in the parking lot of a Dollar General store in Gloucester Township.
That's where prosecutors say Diiorio handed over $500 as a down payment toward an alleged agreement worth approximately $12,000.
The supposed hitman, however, had already alerted investigators.
The Arrest Came After the Cash Exchange
Authorities say the confidential informant notified Camden County detectives about the alleged plan.
Investigators then contacted the Philadelphia Police Department because one of the alleged targets was an officer.
After the $500 exchange on April 4, 2025, members of the Gloucester Township Police Department's Special Response Team arrested Diiorio.
She was initially charged in New Jersey with attempted murder, conspiracy to commit murder and a drug-related offense.
Those state charges were later dismissed after federal prosecutors took over the case following the new federal indictment.
Prosecutors Say It Wasn't the First Alleged Attempt
One of the more disturbing allegations in the case is that investigators believe the Tinder encounter was not Diiorio's first attempt to arrange the killings.
According to prosecutors, Diiorio allegedly told the confidential informant that she had previously been deceived by people who claimed they had carried out the killings.
She allegedly said those individuals had provided fake photographs as supposed proof that the murders had happened.
Those claims have not been proven in court.
The federal indictment itself contains fewer details about the alleged plot than the earlier state court proceedings, identifying the alleged targets simply as Person #1 and Person #2.
A Defense of Entrapment Has Been Raised
Diiorio's attorney, Robert Gamburg, has indicated that she intends to plead not guilty.
Her defense has also challenged the circumstances surrounding the confidential informant.
According to reporting from The Philadelphia Inquirer, Gamburg previously argued that the informant was motivated by money and characterized him as someone who provided information to authorities in exchange for financial compensation.
The defense has raised concerns about possible entrapment and the way communications between Diiorio and the informant were handled.
Those arguments will ultimately be addressed through the court process.
Diiorio Remains in Federal Custody
Following the federal indictment, Diiorio appeared before U.S. Magistrate Judge Scott W. Reid and was ordered held in federal custody pending a detention hearing scheduled for September 14.
The federal charges are based on allegations that she used interstate commerce facilities, including a cellphone, in an attempt to commission the murders.
If convicted, she could face a maximum sentence of 20 years in federal prison.
However, a charge is not a conviction.
The federal case must still proceed through the court system, where prosecutors will have to prove the allegations beyond a reasonable doubt.
The People Who Were Allegedly Targeted Survived
Perhaps the most significant outcome of the alleged scheme is also the simplest:
The two people prosecutors say were targeted were not killed.
The confidential informant's involvement allowed investigators to intervene before the alleged plan could be carried out.
The case has now moved from a state prosecution to federal court, where Diiorio will face the new charges.
For investigators, the alleged Tinder meeting that began as an attempt to find someone willing to commit a killing ultimately became the key to uncovering the alleged plan.
For the defense, the circumstances surrounding that meeting are now part of the legal battle.
And for the alleged targets, the investigation appears to have prevented what authorities say could have been a double murder.
The federal case remains ongoing.
This article will be updated if prosecutors, the court or Diiorio's defense provide significant new information.

Comments
Post a Comment