62-Year-Old Sayville Woman Found Murdered in Her Home — Police Say It Was Targeted
A quiet street in Sayville, New York, is now the center of an active homicide investigation after 62-year-old Rachel Frislid was found violently killed inside her own home Thursday night. Police believe whoever did this wasn’t a stranger looking for an easy target — they were looking for her specifically.
![]() |
| Rachel Frislid |
How She Was Found
A family member discovered Frislid unconscious inside her home on Pearl Court around 8:30 p.m. on September 3. She was pronounced dead at the scene. According to Suffolk County Police Commissioner Kevin Catalina, she was found “a short time after the assault occurred,” and none of her family members are believed to have been inside the home when the attack happened.
By Friday morning, the residential street — tucked between Sayville Middle School and Sunrise Highway — was taped off, with Suffolk County’s Mobile Crime Lab and Medical Examiner’s office on scene. Sayville Public Schools kept students indoors for recess that day as a precaution, though the superintendent told parents there was no imminent threat to the schools.
“We Do Not Think This Was Random”
At a press briefing, Commissioner Catalina was direct about what investigators are, and aren’t, looking at. He told reporters the department does not believe this was a random home invasion. Instead, they believe Frislid was deliberately targeted.
Just as notable is what police say is missing from this case: no signs of forced entry, and no history of domestic violence calls to the home. That combination is unusual, and it’s exactly the kind of detail that tends to point investigators — and true crime audiences — toward someone Frislid may have known, rather than a random intruder.
Police have not released the cause of death, a motive, or named any suspects or persons of interest. Catalina told residents they have “nothing to fear” regarding the attack, a statement clearly meant to reassure the community that this appears to be an isolated, personal matter rather than a threat to the wider neighborhood.
Who Was Rachel Frislid
Frislid wasn’t a private figure in Sayville — she was a well-known name in the local business and events community. Along with her husband, Don, she co-founded Preferred Promotions in 1996, growing it from a single craft show into one of Long Island’s most established juried artisan event companies, running festivals at venues including Stony Brook and Deepwells Farm. She also worked as owner and director of corporate development at Academy Tent Rentals, a family event equipment business, and had a role with Eastern Suffolk BOCES.
She was a mother of two adult children and a grandmother. Friends and community members have described her as warm and deeply embedded in the local craft-fair and small-business circuit she helped build over nearly three decades.
What Happens Now
As of this writing, the Suffolk County Police Homicide Squad has no suspect in custody and hasn’t publicly named a motive. Detectives are asking anyone with information to call the Homicide Squad at 631-852-6392.
This is very much an open case — no arrest, no confirmed cause of death, no named person of interest. The “targeted, not random” framing from police is the biggest clue released so far, and it’s likely to shape a lot of the public speculation in the days ahead. We’ll be following this one closely as more details come out.

Comments
Post a Comment