Four Versions of One Night: The Arrest in Angie Buck's 1995 Iowa Murder

For three decades, the man investigators now accuse of killing Angela "Angie" Buck kept giving them a different version of the summer of 1995. Each time he talked, his account moved a little closer to the night she disappeared.

Photo courtesy of the Iowa Attorney General’s Office


This week, that pattern caught up with him. Iowa and Minnesota authorities arrested Kelly Joseph Grant, 59, of Bertha, Minnesota, and the Black Hawk County Sheriff's Office announced on Friday, October 16, 2026, that he is charged with first-degree murder in Buck's death.

Grant is presumed innocent. He has been charged, not convicted, and investigators say the case remains active.

Who Angie Buck was

Angie was born in Waterloo on April 17, 1958, to Richard and Lorene Buck. Her mother served on the Evansdale City Council. At 12, Angie was named Evansdale Junior Miss; she played violin in the school orchestra and loved horseback riding.

She became the mother of four children and worked as a nurse's aide, including at Ravenwood Health Care Center. Her family said she began to drift after her mother died in 1992 following a long illness, and life got harder from there.

By the summer of 1995, she was trying to rebuild. She had been attending school in Madison, Wisconsin, to become a radio announcer. A former landlord told the local paper at the time that Angie missed her children terribly, and summed her up simply: "She was just a good person mixed up."

The discovery on Pilot Grove Road

On the morning of Friday, August 11, 1995, two coworkers coming off a night shift at a Waterloo tannery went looking for places to set turtle traps. Around 10:45 a.m., crossing the bridge on North Pilot Grove Road east of Waterloo, they spotted a woman's body on the creek bank, roughly six feet from the water.

There had been no attempt to hide her; she could be seen from the bridge. Investigators identified her through fingerprints and dental records, and the state medical examiner found she died from a single gunshot wound to the chest.

About 20 investigators searched the creek and surrounding fields that day. The next day, deputies stopped passing cars to record names and plates. Early on, officials also had to confirm the body was not missing Mason City news anchor Jodi Huisentruit, who had vanished six weeks earlier.

The case went cold. When longtime Sheriff Mike Kubik retired in December 2008, he said Angie's death was one of two unsolved cases he still thought about.

The night on Cottage Street

According to the criminal complaint, investigators established that Angie did not own or have access to a car. On the late evening of August 10 into the early hours of August 11, she was at a house in the 300 block of Cottage Street in Waterloo with several people, including Grant and a second man investigators have identified but not publicly named.

The complaint describes a confrontation in which Angie was assaulted. A witness told investigators they saw someone who looked like Grant and the other man force her out of the house and into a vehicle, then drive away. Her body was found about eight miles east.

In January 1996, an associate of Grant came forward. According to the complaint, Grant had suggested that he and the other man killed Angie because they believed she had stolen from them, adding that she would not be doing it to anyone else again.

Four versions of the same summer

The heart of this case is not a lab result. It is how Grant's own account changed each time investigators sat down with him. Laid side by side, the shifts tell a story of their own.

When

What Grant reportedly told investigators

January 1996

First denied knowing the other man, then admitted spending time with him that summer. Denied hanging around the Sumner and Cottage Street area. Said he did not know Angie, until shown her photo; then recognized her as a former coworker at IBP.

July 2001

Said he was not even in town when she was killed. Claimed he had been living in Florida and read about her death after moving back.

Later in 2001

Changed that, saying he had been living in Waterloo for several weeks before August 10. Still denied any involvement.

March 2025

Recalled stopping at a home in the Sumner and Cottage Street neighborhood where the other man, a few other men, and a woman who seemed to be under duress were waiting. Said the woman resembled Angie and kept calling her Angie. Said the group got into his car and he dropped them off elsewhere in Waterloo, paid for the ride with a bag of marijuana.

Read in order, the movement runs in one direction. He goes from not knowing her, to not being in town, to being in town, to having her in his car. Investigators cite those changing accounts as part of their probable cause.

There is also the IBP detail. Grant and Angie had worked at the same place, which means the man who first said he did not know her had a direct connection to her that predated that night.

The motive that surfaced in 2025

Grant had been a longtime suspect, but for nearly 30 years no charge followed. What changed was a second possible motive investigators learned about last year.

According to the complaint, people in that circle believed Angie was passing information to police about drug activity in the Sumner and Cottage Street area. Fox 9's reporting on the complaint describes that belief as false.

If prosecutors prove their case, that detail carries real weight. It would mean Angie may have been killed over something she never did. Paired with the 1996 statement about theft, the witness account, and Grant's shifting stories, investigators decided they had enough to charge him.

What is still unanswered

Who is the second man? The complaint repeatedly refers to another identified man who was at the house and in the vehicle. He has not been named or charged publicly, and authorities say the investigation is ongoing.

When did Angie actually die? Early reports estimated she had been dead up to two days when she was found, and some case records list her date of death as August 9, 1995. The complaint places her alive on Cottage Street late on August 10. If the complaint's timeline holds, she was killed only hours before the turtle hunters found her.

Where is the forensic evidence? Many recent cold case arrests rest on DNA or genetic genealogy. None of the public reporting so far mentions either here. As reported, this case rests on a witness, statements, and motive, which could make a trial look very different.

A small reporting discrepancy. Some outlets say Grant was arrested Thursday; others say Friday, the day the sheriff's office announced it.

What happens next

Grant is being held without bond. The arrest came through a joint effort by the Black Hawk County Sheriff's Office, the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation, the Iowa Attorney General's Cold Case Unit, the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, and the Todd County Sheriff's Office.

In Iowa, first-degree murder is a Class A felony, and a conviction carries a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole. Iowa has no statute of limitations for murder, which is why a charge 31 years later is possible. The case will now move through formal charging, arraignment, and pretrial proceedings.

For Angie's four children and her family, who have spent more than three decades asking for answers, this is the first real movement in a generation. It is not the end of the story, but it is a long-awaited chapter.

Anyone with information can contact the Black Hawk County Sheriff's Office at 319-291-2587 or Cedar Valley Crime Stoppers at 855-300-TIPS (8477).

Sources

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name