A Water Bottle, a Concert, and a 41-Year-Old Secret: Arrest Made in Hillary Hellewell's Murder



Two brothers walking to work in the dark. A young woman lying still on a quiet Newport sidewalk. For 41 years, that was where Hillary Hellewell's story stopped.


This week, it finally moved forward.


William "Billy" Morton, 61, of Smithfield, has been charged with first-degree murder in Hellewell's death and was ordered held without bail at his arraignment in Newport District Court. The breakthrough didn't come from a confession or a new witness. It came from a family tree, a tribute concert, and a water bottle left on an empty theater seat.


Who Was Hillary Hellewell?


Hillary was 22 years old and from Jamestown, Rhode Island. She was a former University of Rhode Island student, one of three children, and a 1982 graduate of Prout High School in South Kingstown.


She came from a family deeply rooted in the community. Her father chaired the English Department at North Kingstown High School and the Jamestown Zoning Board, while her mother taught first grade at Jamestown School.


The man who announced the arrest knew her personally. Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha grew up in Jamestown alongside Hillary. "We knew each other at least from kindergarten," he told reporters, describing her as fun and full of energy.


The Night of May 18, 1985


According to a court affidavit, Hillary left a party at a Friendship Street address with a male friend she had offered to walk home because he was very drunk. Police said he made it home but couldn't give a clear account of what happened.


Hours later, around 4:15 a.m. on May 19, her body was found on Anthony Street, a side street off Bowery Street near the Newport Public Library. Her shoes were missing, and a soiled blue T-shirt lay near her head. An autopsy found she had been strangled and sexually assaulted. The spot was about 1.2 miles from the party.  


One of the brothers who found her later recalled to The Providence Journal that he first assumed she had passed out, until his brother checked and couldn't find a pulse.


Evidence Waiting for Science to Catch Up


Investigators collected biological evidence from Hillary's clothing in 1985, but there was nothing they could do with it yet. A court affidavit notes Rhode Island simply didn't have DNA testing capability at the time.


That changed in 2004. Newport police sent evidence from her clothing to the state Department of Health, which developed a full DNA profile. Police then tested several men who had been close to Hillary, including the friend she walked home and others from the party. Every one of them was excluded.


The profile was uploaded to the national DNA database that same year, but it returned no match. The case went quiet again.


The Family Tree That Cracked It Open


In 2023, the Attorney General's office and Newport police reopened the investigation, using newer forensic DNA analysis and investigative techniques.


Evidence was sent to a private lab that specializes in re-examining DNA. The testing pointed investigators toward a family whose DNA appeared related to the genetic material from Hillary's clothing. Discarded trash collected during surveillance identified two men who were only partial matches, but their Y chromosome results showed they were close relatives of the person investigators were hunting.


Then came the key conversation. On August 13, 2026, a relative told investigators the two men had a paternal half-brother: William Morton.


A Heart Tribute Show and an Abandoned Bottle


What happened next sounds like a scene from a crime drama.


Investigators tailed Morton to his job in North Attleboro, Massachusetts, and to his home in Smithfield. On August 21, they followed him and his fiancée into a Heart tribute concert at the Stadium Theatre in Woonsocket. They watched him drink from a water bottle and set it on the empty seat beside him.


When the couple left early, investigators took the bottle and sent it to the Department of Health. A September 24 report found the DNA from the bottle was consistent with the profile from Hillary's pants.


Morton was arrested on the morning of Tuesday, October 6.


A Prior Conviction Just Blocks Away


The affidavit also points back to another case from that same summer. In February 1987, a jury convicted Morton of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old girl in a Newport park in June 1985. That park was reportedly just a block from where Hillary was found the month before. The teen said he had offered to walk her home and choked her until she lost consciousness. He received a 20-year sentence with seven to serve.


Despite that conviction, his DNA never connected him to Hillary's case in the database search years later. Officials haven't explained why, and Neronha declined to say whether Morton attended the party or was ever interviewed by police in 1985.


What Happens Next


Morton entered no plea, which is standard because the felony case must move to Superior Court. A judge referred him to the public defender's office, and his next court date is October 20. No motive has been made public, and the investigation is still ongoing.  


Neronha stressed that Morton is entitled to the presumption of innocence and has the right to a trial. Hillary's family did not attend the press conference and has asked for privacy during what Neronha called an extraordinarily difficult time.  


A Small Unit With a Big Mission


This arrest is a win for one of Rhode Island's newest investigative teams. The Attorney General's cold case unit has just five full-time staff members and was formed in 2024 to work through a backlog of more than 150 unsolved crimes. It's the fourth case the unit has solved.


For four decades, Hillary Hellewell's case sat in evidence boxes, waiting. Science eventually caught up, and so did the investigators who refused to let her name fade.


All individuals charged with a crime are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.


Sources


• Rhode Island Office of the Attorney General – "Former Newport man charged for alleged 1985 murder following cold case investigation"

• Rhode Island Current – "AG's cold case unit cracks 1985 Newport murder case" (Oct. 6, 2026)

• The Providence Journal – "Decades-old Newport cold case solved: Man charged in Hellewell murder"

• The Newport Buzz – "DNA Breakthrough Cracks 41-Year-Old Newport Murder Case"

• NBC 10 WJAR – "Smithfield man charged with murder in 1985 killing of Jamestown woman"

• PEOPLE – "New DNA Testing Leads to Arrest in 1985 R.I. Murder Case"


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name