The Plymouth Mail Robbery: The 1962 Heist That Vanished With $1.5 Million
On a summer evening in August 1962, a U.S. mail truck rolled north along Route 3 in Plymouth, Massachusetts. Inside were bags of cash from Cape Cod banks, headed for the Federal Reserve Bank in Boston. The truck made it to Boston's suburbs. The money never did.
More than six decades later, the Great Plymouth Mail Robbery remains one of the most audacious heists in American history, and one of the few where nobody was ever convicted and not a single dollar was found.
Why a Mail Truck Was Carrying a Fortune
August is Cape Cod's busiest season. After a big summer weekend, the banks on the Cape were full of tourist cash that had to be moved to the Federal Reserve in Boston.
Instead of hiring an armored car, the government sent the money in an ordinary post office truck, a cost-saving choice that looks very different in hindsight. The truck carried a driver and one guard, both armed.
Someone had been paying close attention to that routine.
The Detour
At around 8 p.m. on Tuesday, August 14, 1962, the truck was traveling north on Route 3. The robbers had set up fake detour signs to quietly pull other traffic off the road, leaving the mail truck alone on the highway.
About five miles north of the Clark Road exit, two cars blocked the road. A man in a police uniform flagged the truck down. Before the driver, Philip Schena, or the guard, Patrick Barrett, could reach their own weapons, men carrying submachine guns were at the cab.
The two postal workers were disarmed, tied up and put in the back of their own truck. Not a single shot was fired.
A Ride to Randolph
The robbers then did something unusual. They drove the mail truck themselves.
With Schena and Barrett bound in the back, the truck headed north while two of the gang's cars followed. Along the way, the money was unloaded and handed off. The empty truck was finally abandoned in Randolph, near the junction of Routes 128 and 28, roughly 25 miles from where it had been stopped.
Once they were sure the robbers were gone, the two men worked themselves free and flagged down a passing taxi to raise the alarm.
Early reports put the haul at as much as $2 million. The official figure settled at about $1.5 million, the largest cash robbery in U.S. history at the time. It even topped Boston's famous Brink's robbery of 1950, which took about $1.2 million in cash.
Five Years of Chasing Ghosts
The FBI and the U.S. Postal Inspection Service poured resources into the case. The rewards were enormous for the era: the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston offered $150,000 or 10 percent of whatever was recovered, on top of a $50,000 reward from the Postmaster General.
Investigators traced the getaway cars, which had been stolen weeks ahead of time. One belonged to a Revere firefighter, whose 1959 Oldsmobile disappeared from a parking lot on the Lynnway about two months before the heist. Detectives also looked at possible links to an armed bank robbery in West Lynn earlier that year.
None of it led to an arrest that stuck. Meanwhile, the case became a local obsession. Newspapers and the public pointed fingers at people who had nothing to do with it, and more than one innocent person found himself named as a suspect in the press.
The Race Against the Clock
Federal law gave prosecutors five years to bring charges. As August 1967 approached, investigators stepped up round-the-clock surveillance of known Boston-area armed robbers, hoping someone would slip.
Just before the deadline, a federal grand jury handed down indictments. Then the case unraveled again. One defendant failed to show up for trial and was never found. The others went to trial and were acquitted.
No one was ever convicted of the Plymouth Mail Robbery.
The Mobster's Version
Years later, Boston mob figure Vincent "Fat Vinnie" Teresa offered his own account in his memoir, My Life in the Mafia. He claimed the heist was masterminded by career criminal John "Red" Kelley, and that one of the crew spent weeks tailing the mail truck to learn its route.
Teresa also claimed the stolen cash was laundered, with Kelley receiving about 80 cents on the dollar. None of this was ever proven in court, and it remains one man's version of events.
Where Did the Money Go?
That is the question that keeps this case alive. The $1.5 million taken in 1962 would be worth roughly $15 million today, and none of it has ever been recovered.
The robbers walked away clean, the statute of limitations ran out, and the most likely suspects are long gone. Whatever happened to those bags of Cape Cod cash, the story went with them.
Crime Facts at a Glance
- Date: August 14, 1962, around 8 p.m.
- Location: Route 3, Plymouth, Massachusetts
- Amount stolen: About $1.5 million in cash
- Truck found: Randolph, Massachusetts, near Routes 128 and 28
- Shots fired: None
- Convictions: None
- Money recovered: None
Sources
- Wikipedia, "Plymouth Mail robbery"
- The Boston Globe, "50th anniversary of Plymouth mail robbery", August 15, 2012
- The Mob Museum, "The top 5 heists in Mob history"
- The Daily Item (Lynn), "A never solved robbery with strong Lynn ties", December 3, 2020
- Realtime 1960s, "Mail Truck Robbery of $2 Million Stuns Massachusetts Officials"
- Ernest Tidyman, Big Bucks: The True, Outrageous Story of the Plymouth Mail Robbery and How They Got Away With It (W. W. Norton, 1982)
- Vincent Teresa with Thomas C. Renner, My Life in the Mafia (Doubleday, 1973)

Comments
Post a Comment