An 8-Year-Old Walked to Church in 1960. Police Say Her Killer Wore a Badge
For 65 years, the name of the man who killed Gloria Kowalewicz was sitting in a Chicago Police Department filing cabinet. It was on a job application, next to a set of his fingerprints.
![]() |
| Gloria Kowalewicz; Photo: Chicago Police Department |
In October 2026, Chicago police announced that the 8-year-old's killer was Thomas F. McInerney Jr., a rookie patrolman when she died in 1960. He went on to spend 28 years on the force, much of it investigating violent crimes. He died in 2006 without ever being charged.
![]() |
| Thomas F. McInerney Jr Photo: Chicago Police Department |
Most coverage of this case has focused on the DNA breakthrough. The harder question is how a fingerprint the department already held went unmatched for six decades, and what that says about the limits of the investigation that failed her.
Three blocks to Mass
Gloria left her family's home in West Englewood, on Chicago's South Side, shortly before 8 a.m. on November 12, 1960. She was headed to Mass at St. Mary of Mount Carmel, three blocks away.
She was a third-grader who had recently made her First Communion. She carried a small white purse with her prayer book inside.
She never reached the church. Her body was later found in a forest preserve near Palos Hills, southwest of the city, after a passing driver noticed clothing in a ditch and stopped. She had been shot twice in the head and had bruises on her neck. Investigators found enough blood in the woods to believe she was killed there.
A city that had seen this before
Gloria's murder did not land on a calm city. Chicago was still haunted by two child killings from the 1950s that remained unsolved at the time.
In 1955, three boys, the Schuessler brothers and their friend Bobby Peterson, were found dead in a forest preserve on the city's northwest edge. A year later, teenage sisters Barbara and Patricia Grimes vanished after a night at the movies, and their bodies turned up weeks later beside a road in the southwest suburbs.
So when a little girl disappeared on her way to church and was found in the woods, parents across the city had a pattern in mind. Investigators did too. Days after the killing, police questioned Leon Clifford Webber Jr., a man suspected in several child abductions in the region, but he was never charged in Gloria's death.
1,300 interviews and no arrest
The department threw everything it had at the case. A task force knocked on hundreds of doors and interviewed more than 1,300 people, and more than a dozen sat for polygraph tests.
Officers also did something that would matter decades later. They collected evidence at the scene and along the highway back toward Chicago, including a bullet, Gloria's coat, her shoes and her white communion purse. They lifted a fingerprint from the purse strap, and everything was inventoried and kept.
More than 1,000 people came to Gloria's funeral. The case still went cold.
The clue that was already on file
Here is the detail that makes this case different from most cold case breakthroughs. The fingerprint on Gloria's purse strap matched prints McInerney gave the Chicago Police Department when he applied to join in 1959.
In other words, the department held both halves of the match within a year of each other. That sounds damning, but it helps to understand how fingerprint work was done in 1960.
There were no computer databases. Examiners compared a single print against a card by hand, which meant they needed a name first. A lone partial print could not realistically be checked against every card in a city's files, and nothing pointed investigators toward a young patrolman. Chicago police have not said publicly whether officers' prints were ever compared during the original investigation.
How the name finally surfaced
The case moved in stages over 16 years:
- 2010: Forensic testing recovered a male DNA profile from semen preserved on Gloria's clothing. It was entered into CODIS, the FBI's national DNA database, but the leads it produced were ruled out.
- 2024: Chicago police asked the FBI to run investigative genetic genealogy on the evidence, starting with Gloria's coat. The method compares crime scene DNA with people in genealogy databases who may be relatives, then builds family trees to narrow the field.
- July 2026: Investigators confirmed McInerney as the source of the DNA. His 1959 application fingerprints then matched the print from the purse strap.
- October 2026: Police made the identification public.
Investigators also found that McInerney had owned three Colt revolvers consistent with the type of gun used to kill Gloria. Police say the DNA, the fingerprint and the firearm evidence together led them to conclude he was responsible.
The career that came after
McInerney was 24 and about a year into the job when Gloria was killed. What he did next is the part of this story that is hardest to sit with.
He became a detective in 1964 and later worked in units that investigated homicides and sex crimes. He retired in 1987 as a violent crimes detective after 28 years on the force.
He then moved to Nevada and worked as an investigator for the Federal Public Defender's Office, where he received an award for outstanding work in 2003. He retired the next year and died in Las Vegas in 2006, at 70.
The Chicago Police Department did not soften its words. It said McInerney should never have worn the CPD star, and called it devastating that he was never held accountable while he was alive. Authorities have presented no evidence that he interfered with the investigation into Gloria's death.
What we still don't know
Naming a killer is not the same as explaining a crime. Several questions remain open.
- Why Gloria? No motive has been released. McInerney's parents lived less than a mile from her family in 1960, but investigators have not found any confirmed connection between him and the girl.
- Did he work the case? Authorities have not said whether McInerney took part in the original investigation.
- Were there others? The FBI has added his genetic profile to its national database and is pursuing leads on possible additional victims from the same era.
Because McInerney is dead, there will be no trial. The findings rest on a police investigation, not a court's verdict, and the case is expected to be formally closed.
The brother who waited
Gloria's parents died without learning who took their daughter. Her younger brother, Adam, was an infant when she was killed.
He told reporters he was relieved to finally have a name, but bitter that the man police blame lived out his life without facing a courtroom. "He never paid his dues," he said.
Gloria would have been in her 70s now. What she left behind was a white communion purse and a fingerprint on its strap, and someone thought to keep both. Sixty-five years later, that care is the reason her family has an answer.
Sources
- CBS News Chicago, Former Chicago police officer identified as child killer in 65-year cold case murder of Gloria Kowalewicz, October 12, 2026
- Law Commentary, Chicago Police Identify Former Homicide Detective as Killer in 65-Year-Old Cold Case, October 12, 2026
- IBTimes UK, 8-Year-Old Girl's Killer Identified 65 Years Later as Chicago Cop Turned Homicide Detective, October 2026
- Hoodline, Chicago Cop Named Suspect in Girl's 1960 Murder After 65 Years, October 2026
- We Got This Covered, 65 years later, Chicago police name their own officer as suspect in 8-year-old's killing, October 13, 2026
- Original reporting by the Chicago Tribune, October 11, 2026, as cited by the outlets above


Comments
Post a Comment