Maria Ridulph: The Piggyback Ride, the Wrong Man, and a Murder Still Unsolved
On a cold Tuesday evening in December 1957, two little girls were playing in the snow on a street corner in Sycamore, Illinois. A friendly teenager walked up, said his name was Johnny, and offered them piggyback rides. Within minutes, seven-year-old Maria Ridulph was gone.
![]() |
| Left: Maria Ridulph Photo Credit: Wikipedia public domain |
Her murder shocked the country. It drew in the FBI, reached the desk of J. Edgar Hoover, and caught the attention of President Eisenhower. Then it went cold for half a century.
In 2012, it became the oldest cold case in American history to end in a conviction. A former police officer named Jack McCullough was sent to prison for life. Four years later, the prosecutor's own office said he was innocent, and the conviction was thrown out.
This article walks through the whole story. It also does something most coverage skips: it rebuilds the critical fifteen minutes of that night, examines why a 53-year-old eyewitness identification was so fragile, and lays out the evidence the judge never weighed before sending a 73-year-old man to prison.
December 3, 1957: Maria, Kathy, and Johnny
Sycamore in 1957 was the kind of farm town where children played outside after dark without a second thought. That evening, Maria Ridulph and her friend Kathy Sigman, who was eight, were out on the corner near their homes, playing in the fresh snow.
A young man approached them. He told the girls his name was Johnny. He was later described as having blond hair styled in a ducktail, a popular look for teenage boys at the time. He gave the girls piggyback rides, and Maria ran home briefly to grab a favorite doll so she could show it off.
Then Kathy's hands got cold. She went home to fetch her mittens. When she came back to the corner, Maria and Johnny were both gone.
Kathy, her brother, and Maria's father began searching right away, sometime between 6:55 and 7:00 p.m. Maria's older sisters reported her missing to Sycamore police a little after 8:00 p.m. Around 9:00 p.m., searchers found Maria's doll near a neighborhood garage. It was the last trace of her anyone would find for nearly five months.
A national manhunt, and a body in the woods
The search for Maria became one of the biggest of its era. The FBI set up a temporary headquarters in Sycamore, and Hoover was briefed on the case every day. Investigators interviewed more than 200 people.
One of them was an 18-year-old neighbor named John Tessier. He told agents he had spent the day in Chicago taking medical exams to enlist in the Air Force. At the end of the day, he said, he called home collect from Rockford and his stepfather drove out to pick him up.
The FBI checked his story. An Air Force staff sergeant confirmed Tessier had been in Chicago for a physical, was rejected over a spot on his lung, was re-examined the next morning, and was given a train ticket to Rockford. He also passed a polygraph. Agents cleared him and moved on.
On April 26, 1958, a couple hunting for mushrooms found Maria's remains in the woods of Jo Daviess County, roughly 20 miles east of Galena and far from home. Because she had never been taken out of Illinois, the FBI stepped away from the case. Maria was buried on April 30, 1958.
The years passed. In 1997, police officially closed the case without solving it. Their leading suspect by then was William Henry Redmond, a truck driver who had worked for a Chicago-based company in 1957 and who had died in 1992.
A deathbed whisper and an email to a tip line
The case cracked back open because of something said in a hospital room in 1994. Eileen Tessier, John Tessier's mother, was dying of cancer. According to her daughter Janet, she pulled Janet close and said that her son John was responsible for what happened to the little girl who disappeared, and that Janet needed to tell someone.
Janet was only a baby when Maria vanished, and she was John's half-sister. For years she tried to get local police and the FBI interested. Nobody acted on it. After her father, Ralph Tessier, died in 2006, she decided to try one last time. On September 11, 2008, she typed out an email to an Illinois State Police tip line, named her half-brother, and noted he was now living near Seattle under the name Jack Daniel McCullough.
This time someone listened. Around the same period, a former girlfriend of Tessier's turned over an old photo of the two of them. Tucked behind it was an unused train ticket dated December 3, 1957. To investigators, an unused ticket looked like proof he had lied about traveling that day.
In September 2010, state police tracked down Kathy Sigman, now Kathy Chapman and in her sixties. They showed her a set of six photos. She picked out a high school photo of John Tessier and said he was Johnny.
The arrest of a former cop, and a trial with no jury
By 2011, John Tessier had lived a whole second life. He served in the Air Force, rose to the rank of captain, and became a police officer in Washington state in 1974. After his mother died, he took her maiden name and became Jack Daniel McCullough.
Police arrested him at his Seattle-area home at the end of June 2011, and he was formally charged on July 1. His bond was set at 3 million dollars. After he was brought back to Illinois that summer, Maria's body was exhumed. The new examination found she had been stabbed, with three cuts to the chest area and wounds to the throat. In 1958, examiners had never even established how she died.
DeKalb County State's Attorney Clay Campbell first took McCullough to trial in April 2012 on a separate charge: the alleged 1962 rape of one of his half-sisters. The judge acquitted him, saying the prosecution had not proved an assault took place.
The murder trial began on September 10, 2012, before Judge James Hallock. McCullough waived a jury, so the judge alone would decide. Before trial, the defense had asked to bring in the 1957 FBI reports that backed up his alibi. The judge refused, ruling them inadmissible hearsay.
The prosecution's case rested on four pillars:
- Kathy Chapman's identification of McCullough as Johnny, made 53 years after the crime.
- Janet Tessier's account of her mother's deathbed words.
- Testimony from McCullough's other half-sisters, who said he never came home that night.
- Two jailhouse informants, one testifying under the name John Doe, who said McCullough admitted the killing.
There was no DNA, no weapon, and no physical evidence tying him to Maria. On September 14, 2012, Judge Hallock found him guilty. In December, McCullough was sentenced to life in prison. In 2015, an appeals court upheld the murder conviction but threw out the kidnapping counts, because the three-year statute of limitations for those crimes in 1957 had long since run out.
The unraveling: a prosecutor reviews his own office's case
Two months after the verdict, Richard Schmack defeated Clay Campbell and became DeKalb County State's Attorney. McCullough, meanwhile, kept writing petitions from prison, often without a lawyer.
In 2015, Schmack ordered a six-month review of every piece of evidence. He said later that he had expected it to confirm the right man was in prison. It did the opposite. In March 2016, he announced he agreed with McCullough's petition, citing clear and convincing evidence of innocence.
The heart of his finding was a phone call. Records showed a collect call was placed from Rockford to the Tessier home at 6:57 p.m. on December 3, 1957, and lasted about two minutes. Rockford is about 40 miles from Sycamore. Shortly after, between roughly 7:15 and 7:30 p.m., Tessier spoke with military recruiters at the Rockford post office.
Schmack's review turned up more problems:
- Investigators had actually tracked down the number the collect call came from, but never wrote a report about it or told prosecutors.
- The search warrant for McCullough's Seattle home relied on statements the review called materially incorrect and misleading.
- The grand jury heard testimony the review described as clearly erroneous, while significant evidence pointing toward innocence was left out.
- A half-sister's trial testimony about when the search for Maria began was false, and prosecutors knew or should have known it.
- The jailhouse informant had since filed papers, some under oath, suggesting he lied at trial with prosecutors' encouragement.
Schmack even faulted McCullough's own public defenders and appellate lawyers for not challenging how the grand jury was run.
On April 15, 2016, Judge William Brady vacated the conviction, and McCullough walked out of prison at 76. A week later, the murder charge was dropped.
The fifteen minutes that decided everything
Most coverage mentions the Rockford phone call in a single line. Laid side by side with what was happening in Sycamore, it becomes the whole case. These times come from the 2016 court-ordered review.
Time (Dec. 3, 1957) | In Sycamore | In Rockford, about 40 miles away |
|---|---|---|
6:45 to 7:00 p.m. | Maria is last seen with Kathy and Johnny | |
6:55 p.m. | Kathy returns from getting her mittens; Maria is gone | |
6:55 to 7:00 p.m. | Kathy, her brother, and Maria's father start searching | |
6:57 p.m. | John Tessier places a two-minute collect call home | |
7:15 to 7:30 p.m. | Tessier talks with recruiters at the Rockford post office | |
8:05 to 8:10 p.m. | Maria's sisters report her missing to police | |
9:00 p.m. | Searchers find Maria's doll near a garage |
Read the 6:55 and 6:57 rows together. Maria was gone by 6:55 at the latest. Two minutes later, Tessier was on a phone in another city. To be Johnny, he would have had to take Maria, hide her, and cover 40 miles of snowy 1957 roads before that call. Investigators who later reviewed the night concluded that was not possible in winter conditions.
So how did a prosecution get past this? Schmack's review found that investigators in 2008 settled on a different theory of the timeline, one that made Tessier's involvement seem possible, even though the 1957 reports pinned the abduction to 6:45 to 7:00 p.m. That alternate theory was never laid out in open court. Notice the hour-long gap between the start of the search and the police report. A case built from the 8:05 police report, rather than from the moment Kathy found the corner empty, has a lot more room to work with.
The lesson is a simple one. In a cold case, the earliest records are often the most reliable ones, because they were written before anyone had a suspect in mind.
Why a 53-year-old identification was so fragile
Kathy Chapman's testimony was the emotional center of the trial. She was the only person who saw Johnny. Her mother had told her, back in 1957, to remember his face. Nobody who followed the case doubts that she believed what she said on the stand. But belief and accuracy are different things, and this identification had three serious weak points.
She had already picked someone else. During the original investigation, Kathy viewed a lineup in Madison, Wisconsin, and identified a different man as Johnny. That man turned out to be in jail on the day Maria disappeared. This was in the FBI files the judge kept out of the trial.
The photo lineup pointed at one face. In 2010, Kathy was shown six photos. Five were posed high school yearbook portraits of young men in suit coats, set against dark backgrounds. Tessier's photo had a white background, and he wore no jacket. Schmack called the array improperly suggestive and noted Tessier was the only neighbor in it.
Time and expectation do their own work. Kathy was eight in 1957 and in her sixties in 2010. She was shown the photos by state police who had reopened the case because of a tip about one specific man. Memory researchers have long warned that recall is rebuilt every time it is retrieved, and that cues from a lineup can quietly reshape it. Schmack captured the risk well: Kathy may have sincerely believed she identified the killer, when she may simply have identified the neighbor.
That is the uncomfortable center of this case. An honest witness, a sincere memory, and a flawed process can still add up to the wrong man.
What the judge never weighed
Judge Hallock convicted McCullough without seeing several pieces of evidence that later freed him. Some were excluded by ruling, some were never handed over, and some only surfaced after trial.
Evidence | What it showed | Why the judge did not weigh it |
|---|---|---|
1957 FBI reports on Tessier's day | Air Force records and agents confirmed his Chicago exams and trip to Rockford | Ruled inadmissible hearsay before trial |
Kathy's 1957 lineup pick | She once named a different man, who was in jail that day | Part of the excluded FBI files |
The collect call's phone number | Placed Tessier in Rockford at 6:57 p.m. | Investigators found it but never filed a report or told prosecutors |
Grand jury record | Testimony later called erroneous, with evidence of innocence left out | Never challenged by the defense |
Informant's later filings | Suggested he lied on the stand, with prosecutors' encouragement | Surfaced after the conviction |
Each row on its own might have been explained away. Together, they describe a case that was built around a suspect rather than around the evidence. Schmack's review summed it up bluntly: more than 2,700 pages of older police and FBI reports gave no support for treating Tessier as a viable suspect at all.
Declared innocent, paid millions, and still blamed
In April 2017, Judge William Brady granted McCullough a certificate of innocence, a formal finding that he did not commit the crime. That same month, he filed a federal lawsuit accusing police and prosecutors in Illinois and Washington of framing him.
The settlements added up over the next three years:
Year | Who paid | Amount |
|---|---|---|
2017 | City of Sycamore | 350,000 dollars |
2020 | City of Seattle | 300,000 dollars |
2020 | State of Illinois (lawsuit) | 3,975,000 dollars |
State of Illinois (wrongful imprisonment compensation) | 95,000 dollars |
DeKalb County paid him nothing.
Maria's family never accepted any of it. Her brother, Charles Ridulph, hired a lawyer and asked the court to appoint a special prosecutor to retry McCullough, arguing Schmack had a conflict of interest. Judge Brady turned the request down in August 2016. Outside court, Maria's sister Pat Quinn told reporters she still believed McCullough killed her sister. One of McCullough's own half-sisters, Mary Hunt, said she remained unconvinced too.
Schmack had predicted this. He acknowledged that many of his own neighbors in Sycamore would never believe McCullough was not responsible. For a town that had carried Maria's loss for nearly six decades, the 2012 verdict had felt like an ending. Losing it meant losing that ending all over again.
The questions that remain
Nearly 69 years after Maria walked away from that corner, no one stands convicted of her murder. These are the questions still hanging over the case.
Who was Johnny? In 2016, Illinois State Police confirmed they were looking at a new suspect after Schmack passed along information. That person has never been publicly charged. The older theory pointing to truck driver William Henry Redmond, who died in 1992, was never tested in court.
What did Eileen Tessier really mean? She was heavily sedated with morphine in her final days. Her daughters remembered her words differently, with one hearing a direct accusation and another recalling something closer to a suggestion. A sentence spoken in that state carried enormous weight for a very long time.
How did a phone number disappear? Investigators had the number that placed Tessier in Rockford and never documented it. Nobody has fully explained how that happened.
Can memory alone convict? This case stands as a cautionary tale about eyewitness identification across decades. It belongs in the same conversation as other wrongful convictions where an honest witness and a suggestive process led to the wrong person.
As of this writing, Maria Ridulph's murder is officially unsolved. Her family still waits for the answer that seemed to arrive in 2012, and the question of who took her from that snowy corner remains open.
Sources
- National Registry of Exonerations: Jack McCullough
- Northern Public Radio (WNIJ): Jack McCullough Case, A Timeline
- CNN: Oldest cold case, Chapter 3
- CNN: Cold case trial and the witness who remembered Johnny (2015)
- Corrections1 / Associated Press: Judge grants innocence certificate in 1957 killing
- WSPY News: Illinois settlement brings total past 4.6 million dollars
- WSPY News: Sycamore settles for 350,000 dollars
- Northern Public Radio: State police report new suspect
- Officer.com: How to Catch a Criminal, Closure for Some
- TheJournal.ie: US court rules Belfast-born man innocent
- Christian Science Monitor: 76-year-old man freed in 1957 killing

Comments
Post a Comment