A Boy and His Stepmom Were Killed in 2006. The Man Now Charged Was a Teenager
On Friday, October 2, 2026, that plea finally got an answer. A Johnson County grand jury indicted 35-year-old Michael Jerome James of Franklin on two counts of murder in their deaths. He was taken into custody shortly after.
The detail that stopped people in their tracks was his age. When Chynna and Blake were killed in the summer of 2006, James would have been only around 14 or 15 years old.
A Summer Day in Branigin Woods
On July 24, 2006, Sean Dickus came home to the house he shared with his wife and son in the Branigin Woods subdivision of Franklin, a small city about 20 miles south of Indianapolis. Inside, he found Chynna, 26, and Blake, 10. Both had been stabbed to death.
The attack happened during the daytime, in a neighborhood that should have felt safe. That summer, much of the subdivision was still under construction. Investigators have said there were also a string of unusual break-ins in the area around the same time, with items taken and refrigerators rummaged through. Those break-ins were never solved either.
For a community the size of Franklin, the loss of a young woman and a child in their own home was devastating. It also became the kind of case that never quite leaves a town.
Twenty Years of Waiting
Years passed without an arrest. Franklin police kept the case in front of the public with billboards, posters and a $25,000 reward for information leading to an arrest.
Detectives kept reviewing evidence and following leads as forensic science improved. Families, meanwhile, waited through birthdays, holidays and anniversaries without answers.
Then, in late September 2026, the reward was quadrupled to $100,000. Only days later, investigators announced the arrest they had been working toward for two decades.
The Indictment
The grand jury spent about three weeks hearing evidence and testimony before returning the indictment against James. Local outlets reported the charges as felony murder.
In Indiana, felony murder applies when someone is killed during the commission of certain other serious crimes, such as burglary or robbery. Authorities have not said publicly which underlying offense is alleged here, and it would be speculation to connect the charges to the 2006 break-ins.
Franklin Police Chief Kirby Cochran said both families had carried an unimaginable loss for 20 years while waiting for charges. He credited his detectives for staying persistent and leaning on forensic science.
Johnson County Prosecutor Lance Hamner called the indictment a critical step toward justice for Chynna and Blake. He also shared something personal: this case was part of what motivated him to become a prosecutor in the first place.
What Investigators Are Not Saying
The biggest questions remain unanswered for now. Grand jury proceedings are secret under Indiana law, so prosecutors are not releasing the evidence that led to the indictment.
In an interview with WTHR, Hamner said investigators could not discuss many details, including whether James knew the victims. How the reward will be handled is also up to the Franklin Police Department.
That leaves a long list of open questions. What new evidence pointed to James? Did the reward increase bring in a key tip? And how could a young teenager have been involved in a crime this violent without anyone coming forward for two decades?
A Teenager in 2006, a 35-Year-Old in Court Today
James's age at the time adds a legal layer that most cold cases do not have. Because he was a juvenile in 2006, the case touches Indiana's rules for handling crimes committed by minors. Fox59 reported that the case is expected to be waived to adult court.
How the courts handle that question could shape everything that comes next, from where the case is heard to the penalties that would apply if he is convicted.
What Happens Next
Michael Jerome James has been charged, not convicted. He is presumed innocent unless and until he is proven guilty in court.
For the Dickus family and for Chynna's loved ones, though, Friday marked something they had waited 20 years to see: a name, a charge and a case moving forward. For Franklin, it is a reminder that cold cases are never truly closed while someone is still working them.
We will update this story as new court filings and details become public.
If you have information about this case, contact the Franklin Police Department.
Sources
• Daily Journal: After 20 years, Franklin man indicted in 2006 killings of Chynna and Blake Dickus — https://dailyjournal.net/2026/10/02/after-20-years-franklin-man-indicted-in-2006-killings-of-chynna-and-blake-dickus/
• WTHR 13News: Franklin police announce arrest in 2006 murder of Chynna and Blake Dickus — https://www.wthr.com/article/news/crime/franklin-indiana-police-announce-arrest-murder-of-chynna-blake-dickus/531-ef417c65-c7db-401b-b427-5ff68ec202de
• Fox59: Suspect arrested in 20-year-old Johnson County cold case murders of young boy, stepmother — https://fox59.com/news/indycrime/suspect-arrested-in-20-year-old-johnson-county-cold-case-murders-of-young-boy-stepmother/
• WIBC: 20 Years Later, Arrest Made In Johnson County Double Murder — https://wibc.com/898464/20-years-later-arrest-made-in-johnson-county-double-murder/
• Yahoo News: Grand jury indicts 35-year-old man in 2006 Franklin, Indiana, murders case — https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/grand-jury-indicts-35-old-220208212.html
Comments
Post a Comment