Two Babies, Two Years, One Bed: The Bluffdale Infant Death Case
In July 2026, Nicholas Romero announced the birth of his son on Facebook. He wrote that the baby had been "handpicked by his big sister in heaven," a reference to the daughter he and his partner had lost less than two years earlier.
That baby, Atreyu Nick Romero, did not live to see four months.
At 7:13 a.m. on Wednesday, October 7, 2026, Bluffdale police were called to a home on West Napa Avenue for an unresponsive infant. Officers and medical personnel tried to save him, but the 3-month-old was pronounced dead at the scene. Responders noted pink fluid coming from his nose and mouth during CPR.
That same day, his parents, Nicholas Patrick Romero, 40, and Christina Joy Patton, 39, were booked into the Salt Lake County Jail on suspicion of child abuse homicide, a second-degree felony. Both are being held without bail.
The night before, in the parents' own words
The account of Atreyu's final night comes from probable cause affidavits filed after the arrests, built largely on what Patton and Romero told investigators.
Both parents said they had been drinking whiskey on Tuesday, October 6. Patton said she had three to four shots between 1 p.m. and 11 p.m. Romero first told investigators he had two drinks, then revised that to four or five shots of whiskey. He also said he had used marijuana.
Patton told investigators she had taken her prescribed Adderall and buprenorphine (Suboxone). Her preliminary breath test came back at 0.011. Romero refused a preliminary breath test.
Just before midnight, Romero said, he made the baby a bottle of formula, swaddled him, and placed him in a pillow between the two of them in their bed. He fell asleep around 11:45 p.m.
Around 1:30 a.m., the baby started crying. Patton said she took him out of the pillow, unwrapped his swaddle, and laid him on her chest to calm him. She and the baby then fell asleep, according to court documents, for several hours.
Romero said he woke for work around 5:15 a.m. and saw the infant positioned toward Patton's body. The parents said they began CPR while Romero called 911.
When officers arrived, they noted empty alcohol containers on or near the bed. During a security sweep, they also saw items believed to be drug paraphernalia. Both parents acknowledged to investigators that they had intentionally shared their adult bed with the baby, and that the way they slept with him was unsafe.
Catherine: the first loss
Atreyu was not the first child this couple buried.
Catherine Irene Romero was born July 19, 2024, at 7 a.m. She died on October 24, 2024, at about 3 months old, nearly the same age as her brother. She was laid to rest at Riverton City Cemetery after a funeral on November 2, 2024.
Her life was medically complicated from the start. According to her obituary, Catherine was born with a cleft palate and a recessed jaw, and her feeding difficulties required a feeding tube.
In the new affidavits, investigators describe her death as a "similar incident" that also involved unsafe infant sleeping practices.
What the record does not show is just as important. KUTV reports that Catherine's death remains a separate, pending case. The same report notes that the affidavits do not establish her cause of death and do not say whether any criminal charges were filed. No outlet has reported charges in her death. Put plainly: investigators are still looking at what happened to Catherine, but nobody has been accused of a crime in her death.
Why police call it criminal negligence
Nobody is alleging that Romero or Patton set out to hurt their son. The allegation is that they ignored a danger they already understood.
In Utah, child abuse homicide can be charged when a child's death is caused by criminal negligence, not only by intentional acts. The affidavits lay out four factors behind the probable cause finding:
- The parents' alcohol and substance use that night.
- Their decision to put a 3-month-old in an adult bed and sleep with him on or right beside an adult.
- The use of a Boppy-type pillow as part of the sleeping setup.
- Their prior knowledge of the risks of unsafe infant sleep.
That last point is where Catherine's death enters this case. Investigators argue that after losing one baby in a similar situation, the couple knew what was at stake and, in the affidavit's framing, created and disregarded a substantial and unjustifiable risk to their son's life.
That is an allegation, not a finding. Neither parent has been convicted, and the claim has not been tested in court.
What happens now
The arrests are only the first step. Formal charges may take time, because the medical examiner has not yet released Atreyu's official cause of death.
In the meantime, police are seeking search warrants for the parents' phone records, child welfare records, and the baby's medical records. Blood samples taken from both parents are expected to go through additional testing.
Several questions remain open:
- What will the medical examiner list as Atreyu's cause of death?
- Will prosecutors file formal charges, and will they match the booking allegation?
- What do the child welfare records show about the family after Catherine's death?
- Will investigators reach any conclusion in the still-pending 2024 case?
We will update this story as the case develops.
A note on infant sleep safety
Cases like this are a painful reminder of standard pediatric guidance: babies should sleep alone, on their backs, in a crib or bassinet with a firm, flat surface and nothing else in it. Pillows, nursing pillows, and adult beds are not safe sleep spaces, and the risk rises sharply when a caregiver has been drinking or using substances. Parents with questions should talk with their pediatrician.
Sources
- KUTV: Bluffdale parents arrested on suspicion of child abuse homicide after second infant dies
- KJZZ: Bluffdale parents arrested on suspicion of child abuse homicide after second infant dies
- ABC4: Parents arrested on suspicion of child abuse homicide after infant found dead in Bluffdale home
- FOX 13: Parents arrested after infant death in Bluffdale
- Gephardt Daily: Parents of deceased Bluffdale infant jailed for child abuse homicide
- Hoodline: Bluffdale parents arrested after second infant dies sleeping in their bed
- Broomhead Funeral Home: Obituary for Catherine Irene Romero
- People.com (original report)

Comments
Post a Comment