The Boy in the Box: Philadelphia Waited 65 Years to Learn His Name

For most of his short life, almost nobody seemed to know he existed. After his death, an entire city knew his face but not his name.

In February 1957, a little boy was found dead in a cardboard box at the edge of the woods in Philadelphia. Generations of detectives tried to identify him. They failed for 65 years.



In December 2022, DNA finally gave him back his name: Joseph Augustus Zarelli. But the biggest question in the case still has no answer. Who killed him?

A box off Susquehanna Road

In 1957, the woods along Susquehanna Road in the Fox Chase neighborhood were used as an informal dumping ground. People left trash and broken appliances there.

On February 25, a La Salle College student named Frederick Benonis stopped there to look around some animal traps. At the edge of the brush, he noticed a large cardboard box. At first he thought the shape inside was a doll. It wasn't.

Inside was the naked body of a little boy, wrapped in a plaid blanket. The box had once held a bassinet sold at JCPenney. Accounts from the time say another man, out checking muskrat traps, may have seen the box earlier but didn't report it because he feared police would take his traps.

The autopsy showed a child who had suffered terribly. He was malnourished and covered in bruises, and he had died from blows to the head. His hair had been roughly cut, possibly after he died, as if someone was trying to make him harder to recognize.

A city searches for a name

The case became a national story almost immediately. Police sent an alert by teletype to every state, and newspapers named him "the Boy in the Box."

The Philadelphia Inquirer printed 400,000 flyers with his picture. They were posted in shop windows and handed out on street corners, and one went out with every gas bill in the city. Detectives checked orphanages, foster homes and hospitals across the region. Every child was accounted for.

His fingerprints matched no records. Investigators even dressed his body and photographed it in clothes, hoping someone would recognize him. Nobody came forward with a name that held up.

The foster home theory

The best-known theory came from Remington Bristow, an investigator with the medical examiner's office who worked the case for decades. In 1960, a psychic steered him to a foster home about a mile and a half from where the body was found.

At an estate sale there, Bristow saw a bassinet like the one sold in the box, and blankets similar to the one wrapped around the boy. He came to believe the child belonged to a young woman connected to the home and had died in an accident.

Police looked into it and found no proof. Bristow died in 1993 still convinced, and in 1998 a detective interviewed the family again and cleared them.

The woman called "M"

In 2002, a woman known publicly only as "M" told investigators her mother had bought the boy from his birth parents years before and abused him. She said he was killed in a fit of rage, and that she had helped dump his body.

Her account matched a few details, but investigators couldn't confirm it. Some neighbors who knew the household disputed her story. Like every lead before it, it never led to a name.

America's Unknown Child

With no family to claim him, the boy was buried in Philadelphia's potter's field. His first headstone asked heaven to bless "this unknown boy."

The people who couldn't let the case go became his family. Detectives who retired passed the file to younger detectives. Members of the Vidocq Society, a Philadelphia group of retired investigators and forensic experts who volunteer on cold cases, took up his cause.

In 1998, his body was exhumed so scientists could pull DNA from a tooth. The technology of the time produced a partial profile but no match. He was reburied at Ivy Hill Cemetery under a new stone with a carved lamb and the words "America's Unknown Child."

2022: The name comes back

The breakthrough came from forensic genetic genealogy. This is the same method that identified the Golden State Killer in 2018: comparing DNA to people who have uploaded their profiles to public genealogy databases, then building family trees backward.

In 2019, a court ordered a second exhumation to collect better samples. Colleen Fitzpatrick and Identifinders International took on the work. The DNA was so degraded that she later said it took two and a half years just to make it usable, with help from experts in several countries.

The resulting profile pointed investigators toward relatives on the boy's mother's side. Detectives then tracked down a birth certificate, and DNA from the father's side confirmed the match.

On December 8, 2022, Philadelphia police announced his name: Joseph Augustus Zarelli. He was born January 13, 1953, and had just turned 4 when he died. Police said both of his parents are dead but that he has living brothers and sisters, and they kept the parents' names private out of respect for those siblings.

In January 2023, on what would have been his 70th birthday, a new headstone bearing his name was dedicated at Ivy Hill Cemetery.

Why a name didn't solve the murder

It's natural to assume that once police knew who Joseph was, finding his killer would follow quickly. More than three years later, no one has been charged. Here's why that isn't as surprising as it sounds.

He was never reported missing. Police said Joseph likely lived in West Philadelphia, near 61st and Market streets. In 1957, nobody went to the police to say a 4-year-old had disappeared. That silence is one of the most disturbing facts in the case, and it suggests the people closest to him had reasons not to come forward.

The people who knew the most are gone. Police confirmed that both of his parents are dead. Later reports said his parents separated around the time his body was found and died in 1991 and 2014. Anyone who was an adult in that household in 1957 would be close to 100 or older today.

Police have suspicions but can't share them. At the 2022 announcement, homicide Captain Jason Smith said investigators had suspicions about who was responsible. He said sharing them would be irresponsible while the investigation was active.

A trial may never happen. You can't prosecute someone who has died. If investigators become confident the killer is no longer alive, the case could be closed without an arrest. Police call this an "exceptional clearance." It's the most likely ending here, but it would still mean an official answer to who killed him.

The case also shows how a child can fall through every crack. In 1957 there was no system of mandated reporters, no child abuse hotline and no routine way for a doctor or teacher to flag a starving, bruised preschooler. Most US states didn't pass laws requiring professionals to report suspected abuse until the 1960s.

The questions that remain

Joseph has his name back, but most of his story is still missing:

  • Who was caring for him in the months before he died, and why was he starving?
  • Who struck the blows that killed him?
  • Who drove his body to Fox Chase, miles from his West Philadelphia home?
  • Did anyone who saw him in those years suspect something was wrong?

Police have said they still need the public's help filling in Joseph's life story. Even a small memory, such as a neighbor recalling a little boy who suddenly wasn't around anymore, could matter.

Anyone with information can contact the Philadelphia Police Department's tip line at 215-686-TIPS (8477).

If you followed our coverage of the Malik Woodard case in Baltimore, you'll notice how much has changed since 1957, and how much hasn't. Infants and young children still can't ask for help on their own.

Sources

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name