Crystal Reyes: The Little Girl Whose Case Took Decades to Unravel

On the afternoon of October 18, 2026, Mexican federal agents detained a 60-year-old woman in Xochitepec, a city in the state of Morelos. For the U.S. Marshals Service, it closed out a manhunt that had run for more than 12 years. For a little girl named Crystal Reyes, it reopened the last unfinished chapter of a case that began with an unrecorded birth and ended in an unmarked desert grave.



The woman is Anna Marlene Somoza, also known as Anna Marlene Reyes. She is Crystal's mother, and she is charged with first-degree murder in her daughter's 1997 death. She has not been tried or convicted, and she is now awaiting extradition to Arizona.

Crystal's story has been told before, mostly in short news briefs. What those briefs rarely explain is how long the truth sat within reach. Investigators had a strong lead on who the desert bones belonged to by early 2000. The name didn't become official until 2014, and the reasons had little to do with forensic science.

A birth that left no paper trail

Crystal was born on November 26, 1993, at a clinic in Nogales, Mexico, where her mother grew up. According to the U.S. Marshals, the birth was never documented. That single fact would shape everything that came after, because a child with no records can disappear without anyone officially noticing.

Her father was Darren Stockwell, a former Maricopa County detention officer who had dated Anna Reyes after she was paroled from a marijuana trafficking sentence in 1992. Their relationship ended before Crystal was born. Stockwell later testified that he was never sure the pregnancy was his, and he did not know he had a daughter.

Within days of the birth, Reyes brought Crystal back to Arizona and tried to give her away. Family friends Sergio Cazares and Mayda Diaz took the newborn, on the condition that Reyes complete adoption paperwork. After about a week with no paperwork, they returned her. Crystal was then sent to Mexico to live with her grandmother, which is where she spent most of her short life.

The house below Shadow Rock

By the time Crystal came back to Arizona, her mother was living with Avelino Tamala, a former narcotics detective with the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office. Reyes had worked as his confidential informant. When an internal affairs investigation found the two were living together, Tamala was ordered to end the relationship. He refused and resigned in 1995.

According to court records reported by the Arizona Center for Investigative Reporting, the couple then went into the marijuana trade themselves. They rented a five-bedroom home in a gated Ahwatukee community, backing onto a small mountain called Shadow Rock. Reyes' three older children lived there, along with a young live-in housekeeper and, for a time, a teenage niece.

Crystal arrived in November 1996, just after her third birthday. Witnesses later testified that she was treated differently from the start. She ate alone after everyone else, slept on the floor of a closet, and had her curls shaved off with clippers.

The housekeeper, Maria Gutierrez-Diaz, told investigators the abuse escalated over the following months. She described Crystal being tied up, and then kept for weeks in a small plastic dog crate in a utility room. Prosecutors later described the same conditions in court. By spring, the housekeeper said, the little girl had stopped eating.

April 1997: one man's account of her death

The only detailed account of the night Crystal died comes from Avelino Tamala himself. He gave it to federal investigators in December 1999, under an agreement that protected his statements from being used against him at the time. It has never been tested against Reyes' version, because she has never been questioned in court.

In Tamala's telling, Reyes wrapped a towel around Crystal's head with packing tape and placed her in a cardboard box in the garage. The couple then went on a bike ride for more than an hour. When they returned, Tamala said, Crystal was dead. He said he tried to revive her, and that Reyes refused to call 911.

That night, they drove her body southwest of Phoenix along State Route 238 and buried her in the desert near the community of Mobile. Forensic experts at Tamala's trial could not agree on an exact cause of death. The remains that were eventually recovered were too incomplete to settle it.

Bones in the desert

In late November 1998, roughly 19 months after the burial, a quail hunter near Mobile came across what looked like pieces of bone. Police confirmed they were human, about 17 fragments of a small child's skull. With no missing-child report to match them to, they went to the medical examiner's office as unidentified remains.

Crystal was never reported missing. When old family friends asked about her in 1998, Reyes told them the girl was living in Mexico. But Tamala reportedly told Sergio Cazares that Crystal was dead and buried where no one would find her. Cazares went to the sheriff's office, and a homicide investigation opened in early 1999.

After Tamala's December 1999 interview, detectives searched the site he described and found nothing. Then, in January 2000, a call to the medical examiner turned up the skull fragments recovered the year before. Detective Michael Meislish linked them to Crystal and obtained Reyes' DNA through the federal drug case against the couple. To confirm the match, he still needed a sample from the father. That sample was not collected, and the case went cold.

The 14-year gap wasn't a science problem

Crystal's case is often filed alongside modern cold cases cracked by new DNA technology. That framing doesn't really fit. The test that finally identified her in 2014 was a standard parent-to-child DNA comparison, using a sample from her father. What was missing for 14 years wasn't the technology. It was the sample, and the people who could explain what happened.

Three gaps stand out in the investigative record:

  • The father was never asked. Darren Stockwell testified that a detective left a business card on his door in 1998, and then he heard nothing for 16 years. Records reviewed by reporters don't explain why he wasn't asked for DNA. When a cold case detective finally visited him on August 1, 2014, Stockwell asked why no one had come sooner. The detective's answer was "I don't know."
  • The key witness was never interviewed. Detectives couldn't locate the housekeeper who saw the abuse firsthand. She wasn't questioned until 2013, and only came forward fully a year later. She told investigators she had been too afraid to speak, partly because she believed Tamala was still a police officer.
  • The mother was in custody, then deported. Reyes served about eight years of a 10-year federal sentence on the drug charges. She was deported to Mexico in 2008. The murder indictment didn't come until December 2014, six years after she had already left the country.

The case only came back to life because of one person's persistence. In 2013, an ATF agent who had worked the original drug case, Joseph Slatalla, was nearing retirement and contacted the Maricopa County Attorney's cold case unit. Detective Dennis Olson reopened the file and found the gaps that had been sitting there since 2000.

None of this shifts responsibility for Crystal's death. But it does explain why a woman now charged with her murder spent years in American custody without facing that charge, and why it took a 12-year manhunt to bring her back.

One conviction, one fugitive

On December 12, 2014, a Maricopa County grand jury indicted both Tamala and Reyes on first-degree murder charges. U.S. Marshals arrested Tamala without incident. He had already served 10 years in federal prison on the drug conviction and was on probation.

Reyes was nowhere to be found. The county attorney's office put out public appeals for her, listing her alias, Anna Marlene Somoza.

Tamala's trial opened in October 2016. On November 8, 2016, after less than a day of deliberations, the jury found him guilty of first-degree murder. He was sentenced to life in prison. Crystal's father sat in the front row as the verdict was read.

For the next decade, the case had a conviction but no ending. Investigators believed Reyes was in Mexico, protected in part by her family's connections to drug cartels. In October 2022, U.S. authorities obtained a provisional arrest warrant to support her extradition.

The arrest in Xochitepec

In 2026, the U.S. Marshals designated the search for Reyes a major case, which brought in additional resources. In September, task force members developed information that she was in the area of Cuernavaca, the capital of Morelos.

On October 18, 2026, at about 2:27 p.m. local time, agents from Mexico's Attorney General's Office (FGR), working with Interpol, and the federal Secretariat of Security and Citizen Protection detained her in nearby Xochitepec. She is 60 years old. "No one can hide from American justice forever," said U.S. Attorney Timothy Courchaine for the District of Arizona.

U.S. and Mexican authorities are now working on her extradition. If she is returned to Arizona, she will face the first-degree murder charge from 2014 in Maricopa County Superior Court. She is presumed innocent, and the account of Crystal's death given by her co-defendant has never been tested against her own.

If the case goes to trial, it would be the first time Crystal's mother answers in court for what happened in that Ahwatukee house, nearly three decades later.

Was Crystal 3 or 4?

This week's coverage describes Crystal as 4 years old. Older reports are split: the 2014 indictment announcement also called her 4, but the 2016 conviction release and trial coverage called her 3. Her documented birth date settles it. Born November 26, 1993, and killed in April 1997, Crystal was 3 years and about 5 months old when she died. She would have turned 4 that November.

Case timeline

Date

What happened

Nov 26, 1993

Crystal is born in Nogales, Mexico; the birth is not documented

Nov 1996

Crystal, just turned 3, comes to live with her mother and Tamala in Ahwatukee

April 1997

Crystal dies; her body is buried in the desert near Mobile, Arizona

Nov 1998

A hunter finds skull fragments near Mobile

Early 1999

Phoenix police open a homicide investigation

Jan 2000

Detectives link the unidentified fragments to Crystal; the case later goes cold

2008

Reyes is deported to Mexico after serving time on federal drug charges

2013

A retiring ATF agent prompts the county's cold case unit to reopen the file

Aug 2014

DNA from Crystal's father confirms her identity

Dec 12, 2014

Tamala and Reyes are indicted for first-degree murder; Tamala is arrested

Nov 8, 2016

A jury convicts Tamala; he is later sentenced to life in prison

Oct 2022

A provisional arrest warrant is issued to support Reyes' extradition

Oct 18, 2026

Reyes, 60, is detained in Xochitepec, Morelos, Mexico

Sources

  • U.S. Marshals Service, "12-Year Fugitive Wanted in Child Murder Cold Case Detained in Mexico" (October 2026): usmarshals.gov
  • KTAR News, "Arizona fugitive detained in Mexico 12 years after arrest warrant issued" (October 18, 2026): ktar.com
  • FOX 10 Phoenix, "Arizona woman wanted in cold-case murder of her child detained in Mexico" (October 2026): fox10phoenix.com
  • AZFamily, "Fugitive Arizona mother detained in Mexico in daughter's brutal death" (October 19, 2026): azfamily.com
  • WKRC Local 12, "After 12 years on the run, woman wanted in US for daughter's death detained in Mexico" (October 19, 2026): local12.com
  • Arizona Center for Investigative Reporting, via NBC News, "Crystal's Cage: A Tragic Story of Child Abuse, Drug Dealing and Murder" (2016): nbcnews.com
  • Maricopa County Attorney's Office, "Cold Case Investigation Leads to Charges for 1997 Child Murder" (December 19, 2014): maricopacountyattorney.org
  • Maricopa County Attorney's Office, "Avelino Tamala Convicted of Murdering Little Girl Almost 20 Years Ago" (November 10, 2016): maricopacountyattorney.org
  • Associated Press, via The Washington Times, "Man charged in 1998 murder of Arizona girl" (December 19, 2014): washingtontimes.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name