A Mother Said She Left Her Son in the Car. When She Returned, He Was Gone

The stretch of 112th Avenue NE in Bellevue, Washington, is an unremarkable place to lose a child. A tall concrete sound wall runs along one side, curving with the State Route 520 freeway. Cars pass constantly. On the morning of November 6, 2011, a silver 1998 Acura Integra sat parked along that road.

According to the woman who parked it, her two-year-old son was asleep in the back seat. When she came back, he was gone.

Sky Elijah Metalwala has not been seen since. He was born on September 6, 2009, which means he turned 17 this fall. Fifteen years after he vanished, nobody has been charged, no one has been named a suspect, and Bellevue police have spent much of that time publicly asking one person to talk to them: his mother, Julia Biryukova.

Missing-person flyer for Sky Metalwala
Source: Washington State Patrol


This article walks through what she said happened, what investigators found, and the legal reasoning behind a decision that has frustrated the public for years. It also lays her account side by side with the evidence, so you can see exactly where the story and the facts part ways.

The morning of November 6, 2011

Biryukova told police that Sky woke up sick at their apartment in Redmond. She said she buckled him into his car seat, put his four-year-old sister Maile in the car too, and headed for Overlake Medical Center in Bellevue.

She never made it to the hospital. According to her, the car ran out of gas on 112th Avenue NE, just west of where SR 520 meets Interstate 405. She pulled over, left Sky strapped in his seat, and set off on foot with Maile to find help.

She said they walked for about an hour before reaching a Chevron station roughly a mile north. Once there, she did not buy gas or ask anyone to bring fuel to the car. Instead, she called a friend, who picked her up and drove her back.

When she returned to the Acura, she said, the car seat was empty. In total, she had been away for about an hour and a half. She called police, and officers contacted Sky's father, Solomon Metalwala, before noon that day.

What investigators found

The car was the first problem. When police tested the Acura, it had enough fuel in the tank and ran normally. Officers took it for a test drive, and it worked fine. There was no gas can inside.

Searchers covered a 20-block radius around the car and found no trace of Sky. The vehicle was unlocked, with no sign of forced entry. Police said they did not believe the boy had wandered off on his own.

Other details didn't fit either. Biryukova had left home with a child she described as sick, but without her wallet, purse, or phone. During the hour she spent walking, she apparently made little effort to knock on doors or flag down help. Drivers who passed the parked Acura that morning did not report seeing anything unusual, including a child inside.

Then came the question of when anyone outside the household had last seen Sky. Neighbors at the Redmond apartment complex said the family rarely went out, and none of them had seen the boy in at least two weeks. Solomon said the last independent record he knew of was a doctor's visit in April 2011, about seven months earlier. Maile, however, told police that her brother was in the car that morning.

Biryukova allowed police to search her car, her computer, and her home. Nothing turned up. When investigators pressed her on the discrepancies, she invoked her Fifth Amendment rights and declined a polygraph. Solomon took two polygraph tests in the days after the disappearance. The first was inconclusive, and the results of the second were never made public. Police also searched his home and found nothing.

One more detail drew national attention. Two weeks earlier, NBC had aired a Law & Order: SVU episode called "Missing Pieces," in which parents invent an abduction story after their child dies. The episode was rerun in the Seattle area the night before Sky vanished. A Bellevue police major told reporters that investigators who watched it found it strikingly similar. Solomon later said, through his attorney, that it was Biryukova's favorite show.

The custody battle behind the disappearance

Sky vanished three days after his mother walked away from a custody deal. That timing is why Solomon Metalwala has always believed the two events are connected.

The couple met in the late 1990s and married in 2003. Maile was born in 2007 and Sky in 2009. By then, the family was struggling with foreclosures and mounting bills. Solomon filed for divorce in 2010, and the case turned bitter fast.

Each parent made serious accusations against the other in court. Biryukova alleged that Solomon was abusive and that she feared for her life. Solomon said those claims were fabricated, and his filings described her as mentally unstable. Child Protective Services investigated a claim against Solomon involving his daughter and ruled it unfounded, but he was barred from seeing his children for a year while it was reviewed. At different points, both parents sought protection orders against each other.

In September 2010, the court gave Biryukova full custody, and Solomon had no visitation. She offered to give up alimony and child support if he would let her move to Arizona with the children. He refused. His attorney later said he had also blocked her from getting passports for the kids, fearing she would leave with them.

In early November 2011, the court ordered the couple into mediation. After a marathon session, they reached an agreement: Biryukova would keep custody, and Solomon would get visitation. On November 3, Biryukova called her lawyer, said she had felt pressured, and backed out.

Three days later, she reported Sky missing.

A history with cars

The morning of November 6 was not the first time Sky had been left alone in a vehicle. When he was about two months old, both parents left him in their car in a Target parking lot for almost an hour on a 27-degree day. They said they had been inside only 20 minutes, but store surveillance footage showed otherwise. Both were charged with reckless endangerment. The case was later dismissed after they completed probation, community service, and a parenting class.

Her account vs. the evidence

Most coverage of this case mentions the discrepancies one at a time. Laid out together, the pattern is harder to miss: almost every key point of the story has a documented problem attached to it.

What Biryukova said

What investigators found or reported

The car ran out of gas

Police found fuel in the tank, and the car ran normally on a test drive

She went to get help

No gas can was in the car, and she reportedly made little effort to ask nearby residents for help

She reached a gas station to get fuel

At the Chevron, she called a friend for a ride instead of buying gas

Sky was sick and needed the hospital

She left home without her wallet, purse, or phone

Sky was asleep in the back seat

Passing drivers reported nothing unusual; no outsider had confirmed seeing Sky in about two weeks, and Solomon knew of no independent sighting since April 2011

Sky was in the car that morning

Maile, then four, told police he was

Someone took him while she was gone

No sign of forced entry, and a 20-block search found nothing

She did not know what happened

She invoked the Fifth Amendment and declined a polygraph

One row cuts the other way. Maile's statement is the only independent account placing Sky in the car, and it came from a four-year-old who was with her mother the entire time. Investigators have never said publicly how much weight they gave it.

Why no one has been charged

The most common question about this case is simple. If police doubt her story, and she admits leaving a toddler alone in a car for an hour and a half, why wasn't she at least charged with child endangerment?

The answer is a trap built into her own story, and it is the least understood part of this case.

To convict Biryukova of endangerment for that morning, prosecutors would have to prove that Sky was actually in the car and that she left him there. In other words, the charge would require the state to formally adopt her version of events.

But investigators have openly questioned whether Sky was in the car at all. If evidence ever surfaced showing he was harmed or taken somewhere else, possibly before that morning, prosecutors would want to argue that the car story was invented. A prior conviction built on the claim that he was in the car could badly undercut that later case. A police spokesman called the choice not to charge her a "strategic decision" for exactly this reason.

Solomon's attorney pointed to a second reason. An arrest would trigger the defense's right to review the evidence police had gathered. That would show Biryukova and her lawyer exactly what investigators knew, and what they didn't, while the case was still open.

Then there is the larger obstacle. With no body, no crime scene, and no confirmed sighting, police have never been able to establish publicly what crime, if any, occurred. Prosecutions without a body do happen, but they usually rest on strong forensic or circumstantial evidence, such as blood, digital records, or a confession. In Sky's case, police have never announced anything like that.

So the case sits in an uncomfortable place. Police have said plainly that they don't believe her story, and they have never formally called her a suspect or a person of interest.

Where the case stands in 2026

The case is still open, and Bellevue police have not changed their public position in more than a decade. Over the years, their message to Sky's mother has stayed remarkably consistent.

Year

What happened

2011

Maile was placed in foster care after her brother vanished; Solomon was later granted custody of her

2014

The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children released an age-progressed image of Sky at 5

2015

Bellevue's new police chief, Steve Mylett, publicly told Biryukova he was convinced she held the key to finding Sky; police said Solomon had shared new information

2018

Police said investigators from Bellevue, Redmond, and the FBI had followed more than 2,500 tips and put in 14,000 hours

2019

A Bellevue police spokesman told KING 5, "We do believe she knows where Sky is"

2020

NCMEC posted an age-progressed image of Sky at 10

2021

On the 10th anniversary, police released a flyer showing Sky at 12 and said the case had cost about $2.5 million

2025

The Washington State Patrol's missing persons unit still lists Sky as missing, with a Bellevue police tip line

According to police and news reports, Biryukova spoke with investigators only on the day Sky disappeared. She has not given them a formal interview since. She has never been charged in connection with her son's disappearance.

Solomon has spent the years since organizing searches and vigils. On the 10th anniversary, he told KING 5 that the loss was a heavy burden, but that he still hoped Sky was alive. He has previously said he thinks his son could be living outside the United States.

Sky turned 17 on September 6, 2026. If he is alive, he is a teenager who may not know his real name, or that his father has been looking for him his entire life.

If you know something

At the time he vanished, Sky was 2 feet 10 inches tall and weighed about 28 pounds, with dark hair and brown eyes. Age-progressed images are available through the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children.

Anyone with information can contact:

  • Bellevue Police Department: (425) 452-6917, or email pdtipline@bellevuewa.gov
  • Washington State Patrol Missing and Unidentified Persons Unit: 1-800-543-5678
  • National Center for Missing & Exploited Children: 1-800-THE-LOST (1-800-843-5678)

Even a small detail from 2011, like a sighting, an overheard conversation, or a child who appeared in someone's life without explanation, could matter now.

Sources

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name