Stacey Castor: The Black Widow Who Tried to Frame Her Own Daughter

In September 2007, a 20-year-old woman lay unconscious in her bedroom in Clay, New York, a quiet town just north of Syracuse. Beside her was a typed confession. In it, she admitted to poisoning her stepfather with antifreeze two years earlier, and to killing her own father the same way when she was a child.

The young woman was Ashley Wallace. She survived. And when she woke up, she had no idea what the note was talking about.

The person who wrote it, prosecutors would later prove, was her mother.

Who Was Stacey Castor?

Stacey Ruth Daniels was born in July 1967 in Clay, New York. As a teenager she met Michael Wallace, and the couple married and had two daughters, Ashley and Bree. To neighbors and friends, she was an ordinary working mother who held a job as an office manager.

Stacey Castor


That image would hold for years. It took two deaths, an exhumation, and a failed frame-up before anyone saw the pattern underneath.

The First Death: Michael Wallace, 2000

In 2000, Michael Wallace died at just 38 years old. Doctors attributed his death to a heart problem, and Stacey reportedly declined an autopsy. With no reason to suspect anything else, the death was accepted as natural and Michael was buried.

His daughters were still young girls. Nobody questioned what had happened to their father, and nobody would for another seven years.

The Second Death: David Castor, 2005

In 2003, Stacey married David Castor, who ran an air-conditioning business. Home life was tense. Her teenage daughters struggled to connect with their stepfather, and Stacey later testified that she and David argued about the girls on the weekend he died.

In August 2005, David, 48, was found dead in a locked bedroom of the family home. Near his body were a container of antifreeze and a half-full glass of bright green liquid. At first glance it looked like a suicide, and the death was initially ruled that way.

Detective Dominick Spinelli of the Onondaga County Sheriff's Office wasn't convinced. Forensic testing found Stacey's fingerprints on the glass, while the antifreeze container itself had no prints at all. If David had poured himself a lethal drink, why hadn't he touched the bottle?

Investigators also recovered a turkey baster. Prosecutors would later argue that Stacey used it to give David antifreeze over a period of days, then staged the bedroom to look like a drunken, despairing suicide.

A Will That Didn't Add Up

After David's death, a will surfaced leaving his estate to Stacey and cutting out his son from a previous relationship, David Castor Jr. It looked convenient, and it was. The will was later found to be forged, and Stacey would be convicted of forgery alongside her other charges. Prosecutors argued money was the motive running through the entire case.

Digging Up the Past

With suspicion growing but not enough proof for an arrest, investigators turned back to Stacey's first husband. In 2007, authorities in neighboring Cayuga County exhumed Michael Wallace's body. Toxicology showed he had also died of antifreeze poisoning.

Investigators made sure people in Stacey's circle learned about the exhumation, and they monitored her phones. The pressure was building, and they wanted to see what she would do next.

What she did next was almost unthinkable.

The Frame-Up: September 2007

Around the time the exhumation results were closing in on her, Stacey gave Ashley drinks laced with a combination of prescription pills and alcohol. Ashley was found unconscious with the typed note beside her: a confession, written in Ashley's voice, to both murders and to wanting to end her life.

Ashley survived. She told investigators she never wrote the note and had never harmed anyone.

Forensic examiners went through the family computer, seized from the Clay home on September 14, 2007. They recovered fragments of the note and found evidence of earlier drafts, pointing investigators toward Stacey as its author.

The Word That Gave Her Away

Here is the detail that makes this case stand out from almost every other poisoning case: a single verbal habit.

In the suicide note, the word "antifreeze" appears four times, and every time it is written as "anti-free." About a week before Ashley was poisoned, an investigator interviewing Stacey had noticed her say "anti-free" out loud. The quirk was unusual enough that he made a note of it.

That small slip linked the note's language directly to Stacey's own speech. In a case built largely on circumstantial evidence, it became one of the most memorable moments at trial.

Our Take: How the Cover-Up Became the Case

Read the evidence in order and a striking pattern emerges. Almost everything that convicted Stacey Castor came from her efforts to hide her crimes, not from the crimes themselves.

The staged suicide left her fingerprints on the glass but none on the bottle. The forged will exposed a motive. The fake confession was meant to close the case for good, but it produced a computer trail, drafts, and a personal word habit that pointed straight back to her. And by poisoning Ashley, she created a living witness who could take the stand against her.

Antifreeze poisoning can be hard to detect without specific testing, which may be why Michael Wallace's death went unquestioned for years. Had Stacey simply stayed quiet after David's death, investigators might have struggled to build a case. Each step she took to protect herself handed them another piece of evidence.

It is a pattern detectives see often: the cover-up carries more risk than the original crime, because every new lie has to fit with the ones before it.

Case Timeline

Date

Event

July 1967

Stacey Ruth Daniels is born in Clay, New York

2000

First husband Michael Wallace dies at 38; death attributed to heart problems

2003

Stacey marries David Castor

August 2005

David Castor, 48, is found dead; death first ruled a suicide

2007

Michael Wallace's body is exhumed; antifreeze is found

September 2007

Ashley Wallace is found unconscious beside a fake confession note

January 2009

Stacey Castor's trial begins in Onondaga County Court

February 5, 2009

Jury convicts her of murder, attempted murder, and forgery

March 2009

Sentenced to 51 and one-third years to life

2015

Appeals court upholds her conviction

June 11, 2016

Stacey Castor dies in prison at age 48

The Trial

Stacey Castor went on trial in January 2009 before Judge Joseph Fahey. Onondaga County District Attorney William Fitzpatrick called Ashley Wallace, then 21, as his very first witness.

The defense, led by attorney Charles Keller, argued the opposite story: that Ashley was the real killer, that she had poisoned both her father and stepfather, and that she had attempted suicide when investigators closed in. A handwriting and authorship expert was called to cast doubt on whether Stacey wrote the note.

Stacey testified in her own defense and denied killing either husband or harming her daughter. Courtroom observers noted how calm she appeared on the stand.

The jury didn't believe her. In February 2009, after three days of deliberation, she was found guilty of second-degree murder in David Castor's death, attempted murder of Ashley, and forgery. She was never charged in Michael Wallace's death, though prosecutors used evidence of his poisoning at trial.

Sentencing and Ashley's Words

Judge Fahey gave Stacey the maximum: 25 years to life for David's murder, 25 more years for the attempt on Ashley's life, and additional time for the forgery. In total, she would have to serve more than 51 years before becoming eligible for parole. The judge described her conduct as the most reprehensible he had encountered.

Ashley addressed the court at sentencing and told the judge she hated her mother for destroying so many lives.

What Happened to Stacey Castor?

In 2015, a New York appeals court upheld her conviction. On June 11, 2016, Stacey Castor was found dead in her cell at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility for Women in Westchester County. She was 48. Her death was widely reported as a heart attack, and officials did not suspect foul play.

Years later, Ashley spoke publicly about her mother's sentence, saying she felt relief that her mother could no longer hurt anyone.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was Stacey Castor charged with killing Michael Wallace? No. Antifreeze was found in his exhumed body, but she was never charged in his death. Prosecutors used the evidence to support their case in David Castor's murder.

How did investigators prove Stacey wrote the suicide note? Through computer forensics that recovered fragments and drafts of the note, and through her unusual habit of saying "anti-free," which matched the note's repeated misspelling.

What was Stacey Castor's sentence? 51 and one-third years to life in prison.

Is Stacey Castor still alive? No. She died in prison on June 11, 2016, at age 48.

Has the case been featured on TV? Yes. It was covered by ABC's 20/20, Oxygen's Exhumed, and Forensic Files in an episode titled "Freeze Framed."

Sources

  1. ABC News, 20/20: "Black Widow" Stacey Castor Accused in Anti-Freeze Murder
  2. NBC News / Associated Press: Woman sentenced in 2nd husband's poisoning (March 2009)
  3. Fox News / Associated Press: Woman convicted of poisoning husband, harming daughter (2009)
  4. CNY Central: Daily coverage of the Stacey Castor trial (January–February 2009)
  5. Eagle News: Castor trial comes into our homes (February 2009) and Stacey Castor dead at 48 (June 2016)
  6. Oxygen, Exhumed: Black widow Stacey Castor convicted for murder after exhumation
  7. Spectrum News Central NY: Castor's death ends one chapter but doesn't bring closure (June 2016)
  8. New York Daily Record: Appellate Division upholds husband-killer's conviction (May 2015)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name