Who Called Amy Mihaljevic? The Unsolved Murder of an Ohio Schoolgirl

The man on the phone knew exactly what to say. He told 10-year-old Amy Mihaljevic that her mother had just been promoted, that he worked with her, and that he wanted Amy's help picking out a surprise gift. All she had to do was meet him after school and keep it quiet.

On October 27, 1989, Amy did just that. She walked to the Bay Square shopping center in Bay Village, Ohio, and vanished. Her body was found in a farm field about 50 miles away on February 8, 1990.

Photo: The Federal Bureau of Investigation 


Thirty-seven years later, no one has been charged. Investigators have logged nearly 21,000 tips, and in October 2026 a new detective took over the case. The question at its center has never changed: who made that call?

The call: a story built to win a child's trust

Amy was home alone when the phone rang in the days before she disappeared. According to Bay Village police, the caller convinced her to meet him at the nearby shopping plaza to buy a present for her mother, Margaret, who he said had recently earned a promotion.

Detectives have described the story as a carefully calibrated ruse. It gave Amy a reason to go, a reason to feel proud, and a reason to stay silent, because a surprise only works if nobody finds out.

Retired FBI agent Phil Torsney, later hired by Bay Village to work the case full time, summed it up bluntly: the killer was exploiting the love Amy had for her mother. Former police chief Mark Spaetzel has said investigators know of at least one call and believe there were probably more, which suggests the caller had time to groom her.

October 27, 1989: the afternoon at Bay Square

At lunch that Friday, Amy told a classmate about the secret plan. After school she left her bike at Bay Village Middle School and walked to Bay Square on Wolf Road.

Classmates later told police they saw her talking with an unfamiliar man near the barbershop in the plaza. The girls assumed he might be her father. Nobody noticed a vehicle, and investigators believe she was taken in a narrow window around mid-afternoon.

The detail that still unsettles people: the Bay Village police station sits right across the street from that plaza. Earlier the same day, a local officer had given a stranger-danger talk at Amy's school. That officer, Mark Spaetzel, went on to work the case and later became police chief.

When Amy didn't come home, her mother found the bike still at school. Margaret reported her missing at 5:58 p.m. Within days, two dozen local officers and dozens of FBI agents were searching parks, rail lines and neighborhoods.

The field in Ashland County

On the morning of February 8, 1990, a jogger spotted Amy's body in a farm field near County Road 1181 in Ruggles Township, rural Ashland County. The spot was roughly 50 miles southwest of Bay Village. Amy had been stabbed and had suffered head trauma.

She had been dressed again in the clothes she was last seen wearing. Three items were gone and have never been found:

  • turquoise earrings shaped like horse heads
  • black studded boots
  • a black binder printed with the words "Best in Class"

Investigators also recovered a blanket and a homemade curtain about 300 yards away. They believe both were wrapped around Amy when her body was moved to the field. Police released images of the curtain to the public in 2016, hoping someone would recognize it.

Amy wasn't the only girl who got a call

Years later, journalist James Renner, author of a book on the case, tracked down women who had been about Amy's age in nearby North Olmsted. They said they had also received calls from a man who claimed to work with their mothers. Several of those families had unlisted phone numbers.

Renner followed that thread into Ashland County. The North Olmsted girls had taken overnight class trips to a church camp near Mohican State Park, and Bay Village classes reportedly went there too.

That matters because the caller's choice of dumping ground has puzzled police from the start. Spaetzel has said he believes the killer may have known the Ashland County area well. A camp that drew students from both suburbs is one possible bridge between the two places, though police have never publicly confirmed it as a lead.

The evidence, and what changed in 2026

The case now rests on trace DNA and hair. Police have kept Amy's sweatshirt, sweatpants, underwear and socks, plus the blanket and curtain. Starting in 2016, a Florida lab used a vacuum-style method called the M-Vac to pull a tiny amount of unknown male DNA from her sweatpants. It wasn't enough for a full profile. Testing on the blanket and curtain also turned up hair from an unknown person. Police have collected DNA from roughly 250 people connected to Amy or her family.

Date

Development

Oct. 2026

Det. Sgt. Edward Chapman takes over. Evidence goes to labs nationwide, and a genealogist works on newly found hairs. The Amy Run raises more than $70,000.

June–July 2026

Amy's father and brother launch an "Amy Fund" for DNA testing. They also reveal that fur from the family dog, who helped search for Amy, became evidence.

Jan. 2026

Police confirm a setback: the male DNA sample is still too small to test. It stays frozen until the science catches up.

Chapman's view is simple. Killers in 1989 weren't thinking about hiding their DNA, so he refuses to believe nothing is left to find.

Reading the caller through his own script

The caller left investigators very little physical evidence, but he did leave a script. Taken piece by piece, it says a lot about the kind of person police are looking for. The points below are analysis drawn from the public record, not police conclusions.

  1. He did his homework. He had the family's number, called when Amy was alone, and knew enough about her mother to make a work story believable. Calls to other girls with unlisted numbers point the same way.
  2. He understood children. A surprise for Mom gave Amy pride and a built-in reason for secrecy. Torsney has described this type of offender as manipulative and often charming to adults.
  3. He was comfortable in public. He met Amy in daylight, in a busy plaza across from the police station. FBI profiler Robert Ressler called it a bold plot.
  4. He had somewhere private to go. Amy was held or killed somewhere, then wrapped and driven about 50 miles to a field the killer apparently knew.
  5. He kept souvenirs. The earrings, boots and binder were never found. Someone may still have them, or may have seen them.

That last point is why police keep asking the public for help. A tip about a familiar curtain or a pair of horse-head earrings could matter as much as any lab result.

The same script is also a warning that still applies today. Families can agree on a code word, and tell kids that real surprises never require keeping a meeting with an adult secret.

How you can help

Amy's mother, Margaret, died without learning who killed her daughter. Her father, Mark, told reporters this month that he believes the case will be solved and hopes he lives to see it.

If you know anything, even a small detail from 1989, contact Bay Village police at 440-871-1234 or the FBI at 1-800-CALL-FBI. The FBI is offering a reward of up to $25,000. You can also support the Amy Fund for DNA testing.

Sources

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name