The Disappearance of Shy-Shy Pate: What Happened to the Eight-Year-Old Georgia Girl?
It was a Friday evening in early September, and an 8-year-old girl was outside playing near her front porch while her older sister ran a quick errand. The plan was simple: get gas, come back, and head to a high school football game together.
When her sister returned, Shy'Kemmia "Shy-Shy" Pate was gone.
![]() |
| Shy'Kemmia "Shy-Shy" Pate Poster: Missing People in America |
That was September 4, 1998, in Unadilla, Georgia. More than 28 years later, she has never been found. No body, no confirmed sighting, and no arrest. Her case is still listed as active by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation and the Dooly County Sheriff's Office.
This article walks through what is publicly known about her last evening, the hours that were lost before the search began, and the questions investigators are still trying to answer.
Who Was Shy-Shy Pate?
Shy'Kemmia Shy'Rezz Pate was born on October 29, 1989. Friends and family called her Shy-Shy. She was a third grader in 1998, the youngest daughter of Veronica Pate.
She was described as an outgoing child who loved roller skating and new clothes, and her family was active in their local church. She stood about 4 feet 4 inches tall and weighed around 59 pounds.
Unadilla is a small town in Dooly County, roughly 45 miles south of Macon. In 1998 it had only about 1,600 residents. Her mother later described it as the kind of place where everybody knew everybody, and kids rode bikes and skated around the neighborhood without a second thought.
Her Last Known Movements on September 4, 1998
Shy-Shy was last seen around 7:00 p.m. on Crumpler Avenue, near her family's home and a local spot called the Roxy Club. Pieced together from investigators, family interviews, and news reports, her evening looked like this:
- Her older sister was getting ready for a high school football game in nearby Vienna, Georgia. Shy-Shy was going along.
- While her sister rested, Shy-Shy went outside to play, which was normal for kids on that street.
- According to later reporting, she walked down the street to play near a neighbor's home. One neighbor said she ate a hot dog at their house that evening. Others said they saw her outside by herself.
- Her sister left to fill her car with gas, planning to swing back and pick Shy-Shy up.
- When her sister returned, Shy-Shy was nowhere to be found.
At first, the family didn't panic. They assumed she had gone to a friend's house or caught a ride to the game with someone else. That was a reasonable guess in a small town. But when her sister came home from the game and Shy-Shy still wasn't there, Veronica called the police.
That evening, Shy-Shy was wearing a bright neon green, button-up Atlanta Braves shirt with red lettering, Levi's blue jeans, white K-Swiss sneakers, and a leg brace. Her hair was in braided extensions, twisted in front with 10 to 12 small gold beads.
The Lost Hours: Why the Search Started a Day Late
The most painful detail in Shy-Shy's case may be what happened right after she was reported missing. Very little did.
In 1998, two law enforcement agencies covered Unadilla: the city police department and the Dooly County Sheriff's Office. Veronica reported her daughter missing to the Unadilla Police Department that Friday night. According to the Charley Project, the family was told that Shy-Shy had to be missing for more than 24 hours before an investigation could begin.
The county's investigator didn't learn about it until the next morning. Randy Lamberth of the Dooly County Sheriff's Office later told Dateline that he walked into the office around 14 hours after Shy-Shy vanished, and dispatch asked him whether the missing girl in Unadilla had turned up. That was the first he had heard of it. Investigators have since acknowledged that a real search didn't start until about a day after she disappeared, and they have openly wondered whether acting sooner would have changed the outcome.
The 24-Hour Rule Was Already Outlawed
Here is the part that often gets left out of coverage of this case. The 24-hour waiting period was not just bad practice in 1998. It went against federal law that had been on the books for eight years.
The National Child Search Assistance Act of 1990 requires states to ensure that no law enforcement agency keeps any policy requiring a waiting period before accepting a missing child report. It also requires that reports of missing children under 18 be entered immediately into the FBI's National Crime Information Center database, so other agencies can see them. In 2006, the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act tightened this further, requiring entry within two hours.
So why was a family in rural Georgia told to wait? The "wait 24 hours" idea was a widespread myth, repeated in TV shows and sometimes by officers themselves, long after the law changed. Small departments with little training on missing child cases were especially likely to fall back on it. Shy-Shy's case is a hard example of how the gap between the law on paper and practice on the ground can cost a child the most critical hours of a search.
If a child in your life ever goes missing, you do not have to wait. Call 911 immediately, then call the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children at 1-800-THE-LOST (1-800-843-5678).
The Search for Shy-Shy
Once the search began, it was intense. For months, police officers and family members went door to door across Unadilla looking for any sign of her. Investigators searched every home within roughly six blocks of the Pate residence. They found nothing.
The Georgia Bureau of Investigation and the FBI joined the case, and the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children became involved. Investigators also looked closely at Shy-Shy's own family, as is standard, and cleared them of suspicion.
A reward was offered by the FBI, the GBI, and the Governor's Office for information leading to her safe return. Current listings put that reward at $25,000.
At home, Veronica refused to give up. For two years after Shy-Shy disappeared, she slept beside the family's front door and left it unlocked, in case her daughter found her way back in the night.
Why Her Health Matters to the Case
Shy-Shy was not a typical healthy 8-year-old, and that fact shapes almost every question about what happened to her.
She lived with several serious medical conditions:
- Severe asthma. She needed breathing treatments at home, and a week before she vanished she had been hospitalized after an asthma attack.
- Kidney problems. One of her kidneys had been underdeveloped since birth. She had a surgical scar along her waistline from an earlier kidney operation.
- A bladder condition that required special care throughout the day.
- A displaced kneecap. She wore a leg brace, including on the night she disappeared, and was often tired.
Investigators believe she would have needed regular medical treatment to survive into adulthood. That raises three hard questions.
Could she have wandered off on her own? A child in a leg brace who tired easily is unlikely to have walked far without someone noticing. That is one reason investigators have long believed someone took her.
If she was taken, did the person know her? Detectives have said they believe she was taken by someone her family knew. A stranger grabbing a child off a busy small-town street, with neighbors outside, carries a high risk of being seen. Someone she trusted could have led her away quietly.
If she is alive, where did she get care? Severe asthma and kidney disease don't go away on their own. If Shy-Shy survived, someone almost certainly took her to doctors, clinics, or emergency rooms over the years, possibly under another name. That is why her family and NCMEC keep circulating her identifying details, including the kidney surgery scar. A nurse, doctor, or records clerk who once treated a woman with that history could hold the key to this case.
Persons of Interest
No one has ever been charged in Shy-Shy's disappearance. Investigators have said publicly that there are two persons of interest, but they have not released evidence tying either one to the case.
One is a former neighbor who was 18 in 1998. He lived about 200 yards from the Pate home, was friendly with the family, and was among the last people to see Shy-Shy that evening. A few years later, he pleaded guilty to multiple charges in unrelated cases in Unadilla and received life sentences. He has denied having anything to do with Shy-Shy's disappearance. Her mother, who has known his family for years, has said she does not believe he was involved.
The second person of interest has never been publicly identified.
It's important to be clear: being a person of interest is not the same as being a suspect, and neither man has been charged in this case. Until investigators say otherwise, what happened to Shy-Shy remains an open question.
Where the Case Stands Now
Shy-Shy's case is still open. On October 29, 2023, what would have been her 34th birthday, NCMEC released a new age-progressed image showing how she might look at 33. In 2024, her case was featured on Dateline's Missing in America series.
Around the 26th anniversary in September 2024, Dooly County investigators said they had recently carried out another search on foot, which turned up nothing. Working with the GBI, they were also re-interviewing people connected to the case. Investigator Lamberth has said he believes somebody out there knows what happened.
As of this writing, no arrest has been made and no new public breakthrough has been announced. On October 29, 2026, Shy-Shy would have turned 37.
Her mother still believes she is alive. "I am not going to give up or stop believing that she will come back one day," Veronica told NCMEC.
Can You Help Bring Shy-Shy Home?
If you were in or around Crumpler Avenue in Unadilla on September 4, 1998, or if you have any information at all, investigators want to hear from you.
Shy'Kemmia "Shy-Shy" Pate
- Missing since: September 4, 1998, from Unadilla, Dooly County, Georgia
- Date of birth: October 29, 1989
- At the time: 4 feet 4 inches, 59 pounds, Black hair, brown eyes, pierced ears
- Identifying marks: a scar along her waistline from kidney surgery
- Medical: severe asthma, kidney and bladder conditions
- Last seen wearing: a neon green button-up Braves shirt with red lettering, Levi's jeans, white K-Swiss sneakers, and a leg brace
Who to contact
- Dooly County Sheriff's Office: (229) 645-0920
- Georgia Bureau of Investigation: (478) 987-4545
- NCMEC: 1-800-843-5678
A reward of up to $25,000 has been offered for information leading to her safe return. You can also share her age-progressed photo, which is available on NCMEC's website. Someone, somewhere, may recognize her.
Sources
- The Charley Project: Shy'Kemmia Shy'Rezz Pate
- Oxygen: Girl, 8, Vanishes from Her Georgia Neighborhood and 14 Hours of Search Time Are Lost
- NPR: 25 years later, a Georgia mother isn't giving up on finding her missing daughter
- WALB: 26 years later, Dooly Co. investigators still asking 'Where's Shy Shy?'
- WLOS: Age progression image of missing Georgia girl released
- Investigation Discovery CrimeFeed: Georgia mother hopes for answers
- Black and Missing Foundation: Shy'Kemmia Pate case listing
- Doe Network: Case 2244DFGA
- WABE: 24 years later, Shy Shy's family still searches
- 42 U.S.C. 5780, State requirements (National Child Search Assistance Act of 1990)

Comments
Post a Comment