The Valentine's Day Murders of Cassandra Rundle and Her Children
Valentine's Day 1985 should have been an ordinary school day for 12-year-old Detrick Sturm and his 10-year-old sister, Melanie. Instead, their names became part of the darkest case in the files of the Colorado Springs Police Department.
That morning, Cassandra Rundle's former husband, Dave Peltzer, stopped by her house on LaClede Avenue in the Ivywild neighborhood to drop off valentines. He found Cassandra, 37, and both children dead inside.
More than four decades later, nobody has been charged. Colorado Springs police have described it as the city's only unsolved triple murder.
Who was Cassandra Rundle?
Cassandra Susan Rundle, known to friends as Cassie, was born on October 29, 1947. She grew up connected to Morgantown, West Virginia, where she was once crowned Miss Morgantown. Her father, Richard G. Rundle, was a West Virginia attorney.
By 1985 she was a single mother raising two children in Colorado Springs. She worked in an office, was studying pre-law with about one semester left before law school, and had worked with the city's rape crisis coalition, helping women who had survived violence. Her aunt later described her as beautiful inside and out.
She also wrote. Years before her death, she wrote a poem wondering what death might feel and sound like, a detail that has haunted the people who knew her.
February 14, 1985
Police were called to the home in the southwest part of the city after Peltzer's discovery. Investigators believe the killings happened in the early hours of that morning.
The El Paso County coroner ruled that all three victims died by strangulation. Cassandra and Melanie had also been sexually assaulted. Reports from the time describe Cassandra as having been bound.
The crime shook Colorado Springs. A cold case detective later called it extremely traumatic for the whole city, because two children were among the victims.
The personal ads
The investigation quickly turned to a part of Cassandra's life that few people knew about. In the months before her death, she had placed two personal ads in the Colorado Springs Sun, a daily paper that has since closed.
In the 1980s, a newspaper personal ad was the closest thing to online dating. Readers answered by mail, often through a box number, and many meetings started with strangers who knew almost nothing about each other.
Detectives wanted to know whether one of the men who answered had targeted the family. For weeks they tracked down respondents. They interviewed dozens of men and collected hundreds of items from the house. None of it produced an arrest.
The lead detective at the time, Dick Reisler, later said the case stayed with him for years after he left it.
The father who never stopped looking
Richard Rundle spent the rest of his life pressing for answers. He came to believe the killer was a man named Phillip Wilkinson, a soldier who had been stationed at Fort Carson, the Army post just south of Colorado Springs.
In January 1992, Wilkinson walked into a police station in Fayetteville, North Carolina, and told officers his conscience was bothering him. He then confessed to killing three members of the Hudson family about six months earlier: Judy Hudson, 38, her daughter Chrystal, 19, and her son Larry Jr., 11.
In that confession, Wilkinson said he had spent years peeping into people's windows, and that the habit began in Colorado Springs while he was stationed at Fort Carson in early 1985.
In 2005, Richard Rundle told a local newspaper that Colorado Springs police had not taken the lead seriously, because they believed Wilkinson was in South Korea when Cassandra and the children were killed.
In 2020, The Gazette's Colorado Cold Case podcast obtained military records that told a different story. Wilkinson had been assigned to Fort Carson in February 1985, only weeks before the murders. Colorado Springs detectives declined to be interviewed for the podcast.
Wilkinson has never been charged with the Rundle murders, and police have not publicly named him as a suspect. He should be treated as a theory, not as the killer.
Two cases side by side
This is where the Rundle case gets interesting. Placing the known facts of both crimes next to each other shows why Richard Rundle believed what he did, and also where the two cases differ.
Detail | Colorado Springs, 1985 | Fayetteville, N.C., 1991 |
|---|---|---|
Victims | Mother (37), son (12), daughter (10) | Mother (38), daughter (19), son (11) |
Location | Inside the family home | Inside the family apartment |
Sexual assault | Mother and daughter | Mother and daughter |
Cause of death | Strangulation | Beating |
Known link to Wilkinson | Stationed at Fort Carson in Feb. 1985 | Confessed in January 1992 |
Outcome | Unsolved, no charges | Wilkinson sentenced to death, 1994 |
The family makeup, the age of the youngest child, and the assault of both mother and daughter are close matches. The cause of death is not. Offenders can change methods, but that difference is one reason a confession in one case does not automatically answer the other.
What happened to Wilkinson
A Cumberland County court sentenced Phillip Edward Wilkinson to death on September 15, 1994, for the Hudson murders. He later asked to drop his appeals, and an execution date was set for April 4, 1997. The day before, a judge stayed it.
When The Gazette reported on him in 2020, he was still on North Carolina's death row.
Why this case is still open
Three things have kept the Rundle case cold.
The timing. In 1985, DNA profiling had not yet been used in an American criminal case. Investigators worked with fingerprints, blood typing and interviews.
The pool of strangers. The personal ads opened the door to a large group of men with no prior link to the family. Each one had to be found, questioned and cleared.
A military town. Colorado Springs has a large and constantly moving population of soldiers. Someone stationed at Fort Carson in early 1985 could have been posted across the world within months.
The hundreds of items detectives collected may matter more now than they did then. Across the country, long-stored evidence has helped close decades-old murders once it was retested with modern DNA tools. Whether any usable material survives in this case has not been made public.
A note on the ages
You will see different ages for the victims online. Colorado's official cold case pages list Cassandra as 38 and Detrick as 13. Their birth dates, on the same pages, show Cassandra was 37 and Detrick was 12 on the day they died. Melanie, born April 16, 1974, was 10.
Can you help?
The case remains open with the Colorado Springs Police Department, under case number 85-4771. Anyone with information about the deaths of Cassandra Rundle, Detrick Sturm and Melanie Sturm is asked to contact the department.
Sources
- Colorado Bureau of Investigation, Colorado Cold Case Database: Cassandra Susan Rundle
- Colorado Cold Case Database

Comments
Post a Comment