Gun Deaths in America: Why Murders Are Falling but the Total Isn't

Is Gun Violence Really Lower Than People Think? The Numbers Tell Two Stories


A while back, I came across a review on a Facebook awareness page. The reviewer didn't like that the page focused on gun violence. His argument was simple: gun violence is lower than most people think, so why not spend that energy on mental illness, disability awareness, gun safety, or homeless veterans instead?





It's a comment you've probably seen in some form a hundred times. And the interesting thing is that he's partly right. He's also missing the biggest piece of the picture. So let's look at what the data actually says, and why both sides of this argument often talk past each other.


The Part He Got Right: Murders Are Dropping Fast


If you only follow headlines, you'd assume shootings are getting worse every year. The numbers say otherwise.


The FBI's report on 2025 crime statistics showed the US homicide rate fell to its lowest point in 75 years, while overall violent crime dropped 9.3%. Homicides fell 18.1% in 2025, reaching the lowest rate since 1956.  


Big-city data shows the same trend. The Council on Criminal Justice, a nonpartisan think tank, tracked crime in large US cities and found the average homicide rate in 2025 was 21% lower than in 2024, which works out to 922 fewer homicides in the cities that reported data. The same report found 22% fewer gun assaults compared with the year before.  


And this isn't a one-year fluke. Federal CDC data for 2024 already showed the shift starting. Total gun deaths fell 5% from 2023, a dip experts credited to a 15.8% drop in gun homicides.


So when someone says gun violence is lower than people think, they have real data on their side, at least when it comes to murder.


Why People Think It's Worse Than It Is


Americans have misjudged crime trends for decades. According to Gallup, although government data showed crime falling in most years between 1993 and 2010, majorities still said nearly every year that crime had gone up nationwide.


There's a pattern in how people judge danger, too. In 2020, the gap between people saying crime was rising nationally versus in their own local area hit 40 percentage points, the widest Gallup had recorded in three decades. In other words, most people felt their own neighborhood was fine. It was "everywhere else" that seemed scary.


Gallup has suggested where that feeling comes from. Because only a small share of Americans are victims of violent crime in a given year, news coverage likely shapes people's views of crime more than personal experience does.


The good news is that perception is finally catching up. Gallup's October 2025 poll found 49% of Americans believed crime was increasing, down from 64% the year before and 77% two years earlier, the lowest reading since 2001.


As true crime readers, we're part of this. When we consume case after case, it's easy to feel like violence is everywhere. That's worth keeping in mind.


The Part He Missed: Most Gun Deaths Aren't Murders


Here's where the argument falls apart. When people say "gun violence," they usually picture shootings between people. But that's not where most gun deaths happen.


CDC data for 2024 found guns were involved in 44,447 deaths that year, roughly one every 12 minutes. Here's how that breaks down:


Gun Deaths in the US, 2024 (CDC)


Type of death | Number | Approximate share

Suicides | 27,593 | 62%

Homicides | 15,364 | 35%

Accidents, police shootings, and undetermined | about 1,490 | 3%

Total | 44,447 | 100%


(The last row is calculated by subtracting suicides and homicides from the total.)


Look at that first line. The 27,593 gun suicides in 2024 were an all-time high. According to an analysis by the gun safety group Giffords, 2024 was the fourth straight year the US set a new record for gun suicides, and 57% of all suicides that year involved a gun, the highest share on record.  


So both things are true at the same time. Murders are falling sharply. Total gun deaths are still close to historic highs, because suicides keep climbing.


The Irony in the Original Comment


Go back to what the reviewer suggested people focus on instead: mental illness and gun safety.


Those aren't alternatives to the gun death conversation. They're the center of it. Nearly two out of three gun deaths in America are suicides, which makes mental health one of the most important factors in gun deaths, not a separate cause. Safe storage, the kind of practical gun safety that responsible owners and prevention groups often agree on, matters here too, because it puts time and distance between a person in crisis and a firearm.


Homeless veterans overlap with this conversation as well, since veterans in crisis are among the groups prevention programs focus on most.


In a way, the reviewer and the page he criticized wanted the same thing. They just pictured gun violence differently.


How to Read a Gun Statistic Without Getting Misled


Whichever side of the debate you're on, these questions will help you spot a misleading number:


1. Does it say "gun deaths" or "gun homicides"? These are very different numbers. One includes suicides; the other doesn't.

2. What year is the data from? Federal data lags. CDC numbers for one year usually come out well into the next one or two.

3. Is it national or city-level? City reports often come out faster but don't represent the whole country.

4. Is it a count or a rate? A rate per 100,000 people accounts for population growth. A raw count doesn't.

5. Who published it? Advocacy groups on every side cite real data, but choose which parts to highlight. Check the original source when you can.


The Bottom Line


Is gun violence lower than people think? If you mean murder, yes. Homicides are falling faster than most Americans realize. If you mean all gun deaths, not really, because the quiet part of the crisis is happening behind closed doors.


The most useful thing any of us can do is stop arguing about which number matters and look at all of them.


If you or someone you know is struggling, you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline in the US. It's free and available 24/7.


Sources


• Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2024 firearm mortality data, as reported by HealthDay: "U.S. Gun Suicides Hit Record High, Even As Firearm Deaths Decline Overall" (July 2026)

• Giffords Law Center, "Gun Violence Continues to Drop" analysis of 2024 CDC data

• Council on Criminal Justice, "Crime Trends in U.S. Cities: Year-End 2025 Update" (January 2026) — counciloncj.org

• FBI 2025 crime statistics, as reported by the Associated Press: "Homicides dropped 18.1% in 2025 to the lowest rate since 1956"

• Gallup, annual Crime polls (2015, 2020, 2025) — news.gallup.com


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name