Why Serial Killers Start, Return to the Scene, and Get Away With It

Type almost any question about serial killers into Google, and the same four questions keep showing up underneath it. Why do killers go back to the crime scene? What are the early signs? How do they get away with it? And why do they start in the first place?


They're good questions. The trouble is that a lot of the answers floating around online come from TV dramas, not research. So let's go through each one using what investigators and researchers have actually found, including one popular "fact" that doesn't hold up as well as you'd think.




First, some perspective. Serial killings are rare, probably making up less than one percent of all murders. Yet they get so much attention that, according to the FBI, much of the information out there is wrong, and even some law enforcement professionals with limited experience end up believing it.  


Why do killers go back to the scene of the crime?


Yes, it really happens, though not in every case. Former FBI profiler John Douglas, one of the founders of modern criminal profiling, described two main reasons killers return: one tied to their signature, meaning the emotional side of the crime, and one tied to their method, meaning the practical side.


The emotional reason is the one most people have heard about. Douglas explained that the first motive is to relive the thrill and emotion of the crime. For some offenders, the location itself becomes a kind of souvenir.


The practical reasons are less dramatic but just as common. Researchers who study offender behavior point out that a criminal may come back to make sure they didn't leave evidence behind, or to learn how the investigation is going.


Investigators know this, and they use it. Dr. Micki Pistorius, the first profiler for the South African Police Service, said killers not only inject themselves into the investigation but also watch at the crime scene, so she advised crime scene photographers to photograph onlookers and look for faces that keep appearing. That's why police often quietly film crowds at vigils, funerals, and search parties.


One correction to the movie version, though: very few killers openly taunt police. As forensic psychologist Katherine Ramsland notes, only a relatively small percentage have tried to contact investigators with taunting letters, even though it makes for suspense in fiction.


What are the three early signs of a serial killer?


The "three signs" people usually mean are known as the Macdonald triad: bedwetting, setting fires, and cruelty to animals. It's repeated so often that most people assume it's settled science. It isn't.


The idea dates back to 1963. Forensic psychiatrist John Macdonald published a paper called "The Threat to Kill," identifying animal cruelty, fire setting, and persistent bedwetting in childhood as possible predictors of later aggression and violence. From there, a researcher who has studied the triad extensively explained, the FBI picked up on it, and it took on a life of its own.  


Here's the part most articles leave out. Macdonald provided no data in his 1963 paper, and in a later follow-up he concluded the triad didn't reliably predict homicide. Modern reviews agree. A 2018 critical review by researchers at the University of Kent concluded that the empirical research on the Macdonald triad does not fully support its premise.  


That doesn't mean all three behaviors mean nothing. Experts separate them:


Behavior | What researchers say now

Bedwetting | Common in childhood and not meaningful on its own

Fire setting | A real marker of antisocial behavior when deliberate and repeated

Animal cruelty | The strongest of the three, especially when severe and repeated


On bedwetting, one expert noted it can be common in boys until they're much older and may relate to other issues like ADHD, but it doesn't necessarily mean anything in isolation. On the other two, criminologist Matt DeLisi points out that national-level data shows people who have engaged in fire setting or animal cruelty are significantly more antisocial than those who haven't. But crucially, these behaviors don't always occur together in the same person.


The takeaway for parents and caregivers is practical, not scary. A child who repeatedly and deliberately hurts animals or sets fires needs attention from a doctor or mental health professional. That's a sign something is wrong, and early help matters. It is not a prediction that the child will become a killer.


How do serial killers get away with their crimes?


Most people imagine criminal masterminds outsmarting detectives. The reality is usually much less impressive, and much more frustrating.


The biggest reason is something investigators call linkage blindness. Thomas Hargrove, founder of the nonprofit Murder Accountability Project, explained it simply: when someone is murdered, a detective is assigned to the case, and when someone else is killed, a different investigator is assigned. If both victims had the same killer, it's unlikely the detectives will compare notes, and many criminologists fear most homicide series remain unconnected.  


Hargrove built a computer algorithm to spot patterns police were missing. In one case, it flagged 15 unsolved strangulations of women in the Gary, Indiana area, but when he contacted the local police department, he got no response. In 2014, police in neighboring Hammond arrested Darren Vann, who began confessing to killings going back to the 1990s.  


Victim choice is another factor. Douglas wrote that children, senior citizens, sex workers, people struggling with addiction, the homeless, and other marginalized groups are prime targets of serial killers. These are often people whose disappearances are reported late, or taken less seriously.


Finally, many serial killers simply blend in. The FBI's expert panel stressed that serial killers are not all dysfunctional loners; some have had wives, kids, full-time jobs, and been very active in their community or church. Dennis Rader, the BTK killer, was a married father and church council president.


Why do serial killers start killing?


This is the hardest question, and the honest answer is that there's no single reason. After bringing together experts from law enforcement, psychology, and academia, the FBI concluded that there is no common thread tying serial killers together, no single cause, no single motive, no single profile.


The panel also pushed back on the idea that it's always about sex. The report lists many motivations, including anger, thrill, financial gain, and attention seeking. That said, sexual motives do play a large role in some cases. Criminologist Scott Bonn notes it's estimated that sex is a leading motive for about half of all male serial killers, though it's rarely the only motive.  


Mental illness is another common assumption. But the FBI found that although many have various personality disorders, most are not found to be legally insane. In other words, most know exactly what they're doing.


And contrary to what you see on TV, they don't want to be caught. According to the FBI's experts, serial killers do not want to get caught; over time, as they kill without being discovered, they get careless. That carelessness, not a secret wish for capture, is what often brings them down.


Myth vs. Fact


Myth | Fact

Serial killers commit a large share of murders | They account for less than one percent

They're always loners | Many have families, jobs, and community roles

Three childhood signs predict a killer | The Macdonald triad isn't supported by solid research

They want to get caught | They get careless over time

Police always connect related murders | Separate investigations often miss the links


The Bottom Line


The real answers to these four questions are less cinematic than the myths, but they're more useful. Killers return to the scene for reasons both emotional and practical. The famous "three early signs" are mostly folklore, though animal cruelty and fire setting deserve to be taken seriously. Killers get away because cases aren't connected and some victims are overlooked. And they start for reasons experts still can't reduce to a single cause.


What the research makes clear is that serial killers aren't masterminds. They're often ordinary-looking people who exploit gaps in how we investigate, and closing those gaps does more to stop them than any profile ever could.


Sources


• FBI, "Serial Murder: New Report Highlights Views of Experts" (2008) and Serial Murder: Multi-Disciplinary Perspectives for Investigators — fbi.gov

• Office of Justice Programs, abstract of Serial Murder: Multi-Disciplinary Perspectives for Investigators — ojp.gov

• Parfitt and Alleyne, "Not the Sum of Its Parts: A Critical Review of the MacDonald Triad," Trauma, Violence, and Abuse (2018) — University of Kent

• A&E Crime + Investigation, "Predicting a Serial Killer: Is the Macdonald Triad Fact or Myth?"

• Matt DeLisi, "The MacDonald Triad" (Substack)

• The Straight Dope, "Do serial killers tend to be bed-wetters?"

• John Douglas and Mark Olshaker, The Anatomy of Motive

• Psychology Today: Katherine Ramsland, "Persistent Myths about Serial Killers," and Scott Bonn, "Serial Killer Myth No. 5"

• Center for Data Innovation, interview with Thomas Hargrove, Murder Accountability Project

• Big Think, "Catching serial killers with an algorithm"

• Independent Online (IOL), "Delving into the disturbed mind of a serial killer"

• Zaporozhtseva, "The Phenomenon of the Criminal's Return to the Crime Scene," Law Enforcement Review (2022)


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ryker Lee Found Safe: Missing Arizona Teen Located as Parents Face Child Abuse Charges

Anita Taylor: The Springfield Mother Whose 1966 Murder Is Still Unsolved 60 Years Later

Reet Jurvetson: The Jane Doe Who Waited 47 Years for Her Name